Grabban or McGoldrick?

As we are heavily linked with both, who would you prefer?

Easy choice, in my opinion Mcgoldrick is no better than Pilkington so I would rather keep him in the squad than get Mcgoldrick in with extra wages to pay, I don't think many on here see him the one to score the goals to get us promoted so for that reason I voted Grabban as I believe he would offer us something different.

Probably does'nt matter who even Mr Warnock prefers. Like most things in life, it will come down to money and affordability. I expect he would quite like to get Messi, but he will be the same as lots of other players, out of our price range and almost certainly not interested in a move to S Wales. Unfortunately a certain player becoming available does not mean he will be on his way here. I have taken all the names linked with us so far with a large pinch of salt. Like I have said before, I will believe we have signed someone when he is pictured at the CCS holding a Cardiff City shirt.

Grabban is clearly going to be favourite as he is a Premier player on loan at a Championship club. Hes scored more goals this season and would appear a more attractive proposition. Don't forget though McGoldrick is a steady eddie highly experienced goalscorer at this level

As we are heavily linked with both, who would you prefer?

Neiher I think we have better than Mcgoldrick, Grabban is better but rumor has it Bad Attitude , why did Sunderland want rid of him ?

I’d be very disappointed if we went for McGoldrick instead of Grabban.

McGoldrick is past it.

As we are heavily linked with both, who would you prefer?

Neiher I think we have better than Mcgoldrick, Grabban is better but rumor has it Bad Attitude , why did Sunderland want rid of him ?

Sunderland did not want rid of him, he wanted out of there. Can’t blame him, the club is ruined from top to bottom.

He was on loan at Sunderland....they can't afford to buy him. With 12 goals before Xmas, he's class at this level.

Both

Probably does'nt matter who even Mr Warnock prefers. Like most things in life, it will come down to money and affordability. I expect he would quite like to get Messi, but he will be the same as lots of other players, out of our price range and almost certainly not interested in a move to S Wales. Unfortunately a certain player becoming available does not mean he will be on his way here. I have taken all the names linked with us so far with a large pinch of salt. Like I have said before, I will believe we have signed someone when he is pictured at the CCS holding a Cardiff City shirt.

agree....heavily linked seems to mean...by a twitter account that is then rehashed by football sites..even when managers say there has been no contact..
im sure NW has targets and should he get one , it will come out of the blue.

A daft 'Poll' in my opinion (certainly didn't place a vote) but it is what it is

The OP seems to be assuming these are the only two in the mix when we should all know better and it could all change tomorrow!

A daft 'Poll' in my opinion (certainly didn't place a vote) but it is what it is

The OP seems to be assuming these are the only two in the mix when we should all know better and it could all change tomorrow!

agree
if this poll had been done a week or 10 days ago it would be..
Doidge
Jerome
or Madine

And Marriott of Peterborough!
Knowing Warnock it'll probably be someone we haven't heard of, with an unpronounceable name.

glad to see a 100% for grabban

glad to see a 100% for grabban

64 votes maybe he should run for office in South Wales.