Which Deal Neil Warnock did?

Is the best bargain?

You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Is the best bargain?

Bloody hell, that's a head scratcher.... I can't pick.

Etheridge

Sol Bamba, I know fans may go more towards the front men Mendez Laing or Paterson but i think bamba keeps our defence strong and compact, leaving no room for error he is a solid 33 year old defender and has an incredible partnership with Sean Morrison. Our defence is the best it has ever been for a long time.

FOr me it's Patterson, given his performances, age and future value.

Etheridge

For me it's Bamba, he came in at a time where we were really struggling, his character and ability helped stabilise us that season and was a key part in us going up. I'm not sure he is up to it week in week out in the prem but for value and how important he was taking us up for me it has to be him.

Footballing wise for right now, maybe Paterson or NML although Etheridge maybe worth the most if his form continues.

paterson or mendez laing. paterson probably edges it because he has stepped up to premier league level, whereas NML hasn't had the opportunities to show he can yet.

hoilett was unplayable in the championship and so if you asked this question last season it would have been him. he's been ineffective in the PL so far.

bamba has been a big signing. big personality and he is a great organiser, but his discipline and concentration is poor - this is his main failing, and morrison remains the better player for me.

Very very very hard choice,it’s out of Patterson and Bamba..............

Bamba for me.

One of the first three because of their age they will have a better resale value than the older players.My guess is that our most valuable player at present is Paterson as a Scottish International Player who scores goals?
We should also vote on Warnock’s worse buy, it most be Tomlin ahead of Madine?

All 4 have been fantastic signings.
Patterson for me

Mendez llaing think will be unplayable but all awesome signings

Brilliant post so thought provoking.

For me it must be Super Sol the others are great but Sol stablised us with SM when we needed it most.

Cant wait to sing his chrimbo song again!

Think there'd be other candidates .
If you count loans then Arter and Camasarra are brilliant . I think Reid will be special in time but already you'd surely have to include Murphy

Think there'd be other candidates .
If you count loans then Arter and Camasarra are brilliant . I think Reid will be special in time but already you'd surely have to include Murphy

Bamba easily for me.
Don’t see how you could include people like Murphy who’s been here 5 minutes and has been hit & miss whilst Bamba has been performing consistently for two years on and off the pitch.

What does he do off the pitch then ?
No bigger fan of Sol Bamba than me, and I'd agree that he's a candidate for Sir Neil's best signing, but I was just pointing out that he's signed a lot of good players and continues to do that.

Sol Bamba, I know fans may go more towards the front men Mendez Laing or Paterson but i think bamba keeps our defence strong and compact, leaving no room for error he is a solid 33 year old defender and has an incredible partnership with Sean Morrison. Our defence is the best it has ever been for a long time.

No room for error? Do you go to games?!

What does he do off the pitch then ?
No bigger fan of Sol Bamba than me, and I'd agree that he's a candidate for Sir Neil's best signing, but I was just pointing out that he's signed a lot of good players and continues to do that.

He’s a big character in the changing room and in training. A natural captain which helps hugely.
Yes, Warnock has signed some decent players and I like the look of Murphy but he needs some consistency which shows in Warnocks team selections. Certainly not Warnocks best deal as yet.

Etheridge

Bamba