Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 5:55 pm

Marshall Has ended up second fiddle to Heaton is a quality keeper played a blinder against Stoke

Heaton He is a Quality keeper but his kicking is shocking 7

Macnaughton Mr quality Mr professional Mr Cardiff City what would we do without him 9

Hudson Second half of the season what a change . He has been a rock 8

Gypes Quality defender who has seriously lost his way 5

Keinann Looks pretty solid bit to early to call but so far 7

Naylor Shocking has cost us many points 1

Darcey Blake Bad social life impacting on his game unless he sorts himself out its the door for him 2

Burke Loss of form doesn't run a defenders like he used to 5

Whittingham To laid back doesn't contribute. Occasional touches of brilliance and is a luxury player 4

Mcphail Needs a run of games but doesnt do enough 5

Bellamy Not in the game enough and not playing well 5

Rambo Pure Quality but will be going back to Arsenal soon 9

JET He looks good but DJ is wasting him 7

Bothroyd Since England call up has been shocking. The boy needs stabilisers fitted to him 3

Chopra Trying hard will always give 100% and when not playing well he will bug the hell out of the other team 7

Parkin So far not given a chance. He needs to be used more 6

Dave Jones Does not have a clue how to play a quality team, He does not know how to control them or motivate them. A lot of managers would have this club sitting proudly on top of this league. I still believe he is not the man to take us up 3

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 5:57 pm

Good post Nukes :ayatollah: :ayatollah: Agree with most of that. :ayatollah:

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 5:58 pm

Got to agree,with all your post :ayatollah:

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 6:01 pm

Forgot Quinn Chiefs Quinn Has done well since coming back 7 :ayatollah:

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 6:13 pm

Nuclearblue wrote:Forgot Quinn Chiefs Quinn Has done well since coming back 7 :ayatollah:


Koumas, Matthews? ;)

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 6:17 pm

Hallett wrote:
Nuclearblue wrote:Forgot Quinn Chiefs Quinn Has done well since coming back 7 :ayatollah:


Koumas, Matthews? ;)

Koumas What can you say about him not mentally fit 1

Matthews Absolutely destroyed by Jones. Needs to play will become a quality winger 4

Any more :lol: :lol:

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 6:19 pm

Oli, Rae :lol:

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 6:22 pm

Hallett wrote:Rae :lol:

Oh for f**k sakes !! f**k Gavin Rae :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: oh ok i will give RAE a 5 on the count he didn't play bad against Stoke. Any more ? :D

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 6:24 pm

Olli Hasent played as well as he did at the begining but still vital 6.5

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 6:26 pm

I thought it is a 3/4 season ratings not the last 3 games ratings

bothroyd 3 :? yes i agree hes been dreadful the last couple of games

but the start of the season he was our best player by far, we missed him december and january

surely 3 is abit harsh?

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 6:39 pm

Nukes

Not bad!!! But Naylor 1. Well over rated. 0 zero zilch zip would have been closer to the mark. He's fecking useless. We have looked 10 times better since Kev moved over to left and Quinn has been a revelation.
:ayatollah: :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Sun Feb 20, 2011 9:18 pm

Nuclearblue wrote:Marshall Has ended up second fiddle to Heaton is a quality keeper played a blinder against Stoke

Heaton He is a Quality keeper but his kicking is shocking 7

Macnaughton Mr quality Mr professional Mr Cardiff City what would we do without him 9

Hudson Second half of the season what a change . He has been a rock 8

Gypes Quality defender who has seriously lost his way 5

Keinann Looks pretty solid bit to early to call but so far 7

Naylor Shocking has cost us many points 1

Darcey Blake Bad social life impacting on his game unless he sorts himself out its the door for him 2

Burke Loss of form doesn't run a defenders like he used to 5

Whittingham To laid back doesn't contribute. Occasional touches of brilliance and is a luxury player 4

Mcphail Needs a run of games but doesnt do enough 5

Bellamy Not in the game enough and not playing well 5

Rambo Pure Quality but will be going back to Arsenal soon 9

JET He looks good but DJ is wasting him 7

Bothroyd Since England call up has been shocking. The boy needs stabilisers fitted to him 3

Chopra Trying hard will always give 100% and when not playing well he will bug the hell out of the other team 7

Parkin So far not given a chance. He needs to be used more 6

Dave Jones Does not have a clue how to play a quality team, He does not know how to control them or motivate them. A lot of managers would have this club sitting proudly on top of this league. I still believe he is not the man to take us up 3


Agree with nearly everthing you say, except I would have gave Naylor 0.

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Mon Feb 21, 2011 9:10 am

Pinster25 wrote:I thought it is a 3/4 season ratings not the last 3 games ratings

bothroyd 3 :? yes i agree hes been dreadful the last couple of games

but the start of the season he was our best player by far, we missed him december and january

surely 3 is abit harsh?

That rating since my last one was since the England call up. So can anyone tell me what he has done since then ? Diss me again fella and i will give him a 2 :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Re: 3/4 WAY THROUGH SEASON PLAYER RATINGS !!

Mon Feb 21, 2011 9:13 am

Ruislip Blue wrote:Nukes

Not bad!!! But Naylor 1. Well over rated. 0 zero zilch zip would have been closer to the mark. He's fecking useless. We have looked 10 times better since Kev moved over to left and Quinn has been a revelation.
:ayatollah: :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Yeah i can see why you were pissed with that Chief. I can see the error of my ways now pity Jones cant. :lol: NAYLOR 0