Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

I hope we go up on our own merit!

Fri Apr 29, 2011 4:47 pm

Hopefully we will go up by Norwich dropping points ect..

I for one could not stand going up through a points deduction!

Imagine the response- "ah well you only went up coz of that qpr thing"

Plus our opposing fans in the prem constant stick all season.

Of course I will take promotion either way but just won't feel right deep down!

I know they have cheated but still won't feel as good as on our own merit!!
:ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Fri Apr 29, 2011 5:23 pm

i just wanna go up :lol:

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Fri Apr 29, 2011 6:00 pm

Canton stand baz wrote:Hopefully we will go up by Norwich dropping points ect..

I for one could not stand going up through a points deduction!

Imagine the response- "ah well you only went up coz of that qpr thing"

Plus our opposing fans in the prem constant stick all season.

Of course I will take promotion either way but just won't feel right deep down!

I know they have cheated but still won't feel as good as on our own merit!!
:ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Totally agree with your post mate :ayatollah: :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Fri Apr 29, 2011 7:01 pm

Canton stand baz wrote:Hopefully we will go up by Norwich dropping points ect..

I for one could not stand going up through a points deduction!

Imagine the response- "ah well you only went up coz of that qpr thing"

Plus our opposing fans in the prem constant stick all season.

Of course I will take promotion either way but just won't feel right deep down!

I know they have cheated but still won't feel as good as on our own merit!!
:ayatollah: :ayatollah:


Couldn't agree more Baz :ayatollah:

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Fri Apr 29, 2011 7:11 pm

I’ve changed my mind on this and if QPR are proved to have done wrong and get a point deduction I can’t see why we shouldn't take their place.

The way I look at it is this. In 2009 and before last season and this, every club knew the rules and possible sanctions from the FA if they signed a player on a third party basis, used unlicensed agents or supplied fraudulent registration documents.
In 2010 we finished on merit above Blackpool with 6 more points and a superior goal difference so it could be strongly argued that we suffered in affect a 7 point deduction when they beat us to the Premiership. Of course I’m not arguing the Play-Off result was wrong because we were fully aware of the rules before a ball was kicked.

However, the FACT is we did finish above them but missed out because of the rules of the competition.

So my thinking is the very same must apply to QPR. Yes they will finish above us, probably by the same 6 points and the superior goal difference we had over Blackpool last year but if they have broken the rules they must understand that is not a reason to avoid their fate and we should rightly take their place, provided we of course get enough points to finish either 3rd or 2nd

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:24 pm

Canton stand baz wrote:Hopefully we will go up by Norwich dropping points ect..

I for one could not stand going up through a points deduction!

Imagine the response- "ah well you only went up coz of that qpr thing"

Plus our opposing fans in the prem constant stick all season.

Of course I will take promotion either way but just won't feel right deep down!

I know they have cheated but still won't feel as good as on our own merit!!
:ayatollah: :ayatollah:


At last a voice of reason.

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:25 pm

totally agree :ayatollah:

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Fri Apr 29, 2011 10:31 pm

Canton stand baz wrote:Hopefully we will go up by Norwich dropping points ect..

I for one could not stand going up through a points deduction!

Imagine the response- "ah well you only went up coz of that qpr thing"

Plus our opposing fans in the prem constant stick all season.

Of course I will take promotion either way but just won't feel right deep down!

I know they have cheated but still won't feel as good as on our own merit!!
:ayatollah: :ayatollah:

if qpr do go up, do you not think premier fans . aint going to chant, to qpr, you only sing when your cheating, etc, let us take it instead, im sure we can come up with a few songs back? :roll:

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Sat Apr 30, 2011 7:47 am

ninianblue wrote:
Canton stand baz wrote:Hopefully we will go up by Norwich dropping points ect..

I for one could not stand going up through a points deduction!

Imagine the response- "ah well you only went up coz of that qpr thing"

Plus our opposing fans in the prem constant stick all season.

Of course I will take promotion either way but just won't feel right deep down!

I know they have cheated but still won't feel as good as on our own merit!!
:ayatollah: :ayatollah:

if qpr do go up, do you not think premier fans . aint going to chant, to qpr, you only sing when your cheating, etc, let us take it instead, im sure we can come up with a few songs back? :roll:




Yes we will come back!

But can you imagine the jacks! They would thrive on it through there jealousy!!
:ayatollah:

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Sat Apr 30, 2011 7:49 am

Canton stand baz wrote:Hopefully we will go up by Norwich dropping points ect..

I for one could not stand going up through a points deduction!

Imagine the response- "ah well you only went up coz of that qpr thing"

Plus our opposing fans in the prem constant stick all season.

Of course I will take promotion either way but just won't feel right deep down!

I know they have cheated but still won't feel as good as on our own merit!!
:ayatollah: :ayatollah:




I Feel exactly the same, I WANT TO GO UP ON OUR OWN MERRIT and WIN PROMOTION BY WINNING OUR OWN GAMES, SO NO ONE CAN EVER POINT THE FINGER AT US :ayatollah: :ayatollah: :ayatollah: :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: I hope we go up on our own merit!

Sat Apr 30, 2011 7:53 am

Canton stand baz wrote:Hopefully we will go up by Norwich dropping points ect..

I for one could not stand going up through a points deduction!

Imagine the response- "ah well you only went up coz of that qpr thing"

Plus our opposing fans in the prem constant stick all season.

Of course I will take promotion either way but just won't feel right deep down!

I know they have cheated but still won't feel as good as on our own merit!!
:ayatollah: :ayatollah:



Well we all hope that but , we need Noriwch to drop points so really you could say we have to depend on other to help us. But if they do drop points on Monday , and we can also win at Burnley then we would have done it, but to be honest we should have had it in thebag by now. If we had not given away silly goals early in the season.It was again November time that let us down .