" The Bothroyd Poll "

Would you like to see Jay back?

Yes all the way!!

For me, even at 14K a week, it's win/win.

Yes Malky could bring the best out of him

Great player on his day just lets himself down with all the diving.

But its a yes from me

maybe we should stick this on his twitter!

He's a class act on his day, There is noone better in this league for the money we have.

And We need Jay for the Guy in the Ninian Stand 112 singing "Jay Bothroyds Barmy Army!"

Bring back jay please malky, it would cost big bucks to sign someone of his talent and even if we were willing to pay a big transfer fee for someone they probably wouldn't want to drop down to the championship, sign him up quick

Should this thread be sent to Jay's twitter or would that make him ask for more money?

Should this thread be sent to Jay's twitter or would that make him ask for more money?

A big yes from me

im sitting on the middle of the fence

im sitting on the middle of the fence

Doesn't that hurt?

sign him up i say fantastic on his game even if he does let him self down sometimes

No.

Out with the old and in with the new. Lazy Bambi.

When he is on his game he is pure pure quality but he seldom is. To get to the next level we need a TEAM of passionate team players with a high work ethic.

Onwards and upwards as we say here

I voted yes, as long as it's the Jay Bothroyd that played with heart and commitment prior to his England cap, after that he became too big for his boots and suffered with delusions of grandeur.

No.

Out with the old and in with the new. Lazy Bambi.

When he is on his game he is pure pure quality but he seldom is. To get to the next level we need a TEAM of passionate team players with a high work ethic.

Onwards and upwards as we say here

I agree. Its a definite no for me. Have we forgotten the time he shit out of a challenge when a goal would have brought us back into the game? Have we forgotten the times he has lost the ball because of his arse's relationship with the grass?

I do not doubt that man has an exceptional talent and is a fine footballer. He is however, in no way complete. He has no aggression and no hunger or desire. The only person who could get the best out of him is no longer at the club.

I will let Malky make the decision. If he brings him back, I will respect the decision and support it.

Remember Jay, you and various others let us down. If you are to return to Cardiff City please understand this; We understand you cant have a blistering game every week. We know there will be baron spells where you're not scoring but that's fine as long as you play for the shirt (use Mcnaughton and Bellamy as an example if you are unsure of how to conduct yourself). In a nutshell - if you cant change, dont bother - put that on his fuckin twitter!

Nar

Only if he sort his attitude problem out

100% YES

Yes Malky could bring the best out of him

I doubt it Mackay is a disciplinarian and Bothroyd doesn't do discipline.

I put this before and i will again, those that want Jay back sound like a downtrodden ex boyfriend of a Girl who cheats on him constantly who treats him like shit and does not love him. But once in a while she will shag him and that is enough to keep him hanging on on a belief one Day she will love him again.

In short he wanted to leave in January but was not allowed. He then threw his toys out of his pram and he then did not give a damn not even trying. His heart had gone!! but he had the audacity to collect his Wages every Month. But now and again he would score a penalty or a goal and that was enough for some of our supporters to still embrace him. But he would disrespect our Club by socialising hours before a game as he felt he could treat our Club how the hell he likes.
He then left hoping to find very lush grass on the other side but his antics haven't gone unnoticed and it seems like no one wants him,so he is sounding out coming back to some down trodden fans who want him back no matter what.

To me he is a disgrace to our Club our supporters and himself, if he came back he would treat us with the same contempt and for that reason i know we can find better so its a massive NO from Nukes.

All day everday yes

He has been the focal point of our team for a few years and if im honest I dont think we have ever seen his best form

we need him so so badly...

earnshaw bothroyd..
bellamy

at least then we would have a chance of promotion if we could sign two more young talanted attacking players as well

I want Jay back for sure!
He is a class player!

He's class when he want's to be. Would'nt mind him back, to be honest.

Honest answer? Definately. I think that, under the right management, can do what he did for us in the first half of the season. He's a class act when his mind is focused

I'd rather episodes of brilliance over a season of averageness any day, that's what football is all about for me, skill and craft

Big NO from moonmouse..

Yes
20 goals this season only 5/6 behind the top scorer and Jay had two injuries and used the games at the end of the season to get fit. if we had had a reserve side he would have been fitter for the run in. It wasn't too long ago, people were begging the club to sign him up for £20,000 a week. By next week we could have Jay, Earnie and Bellers signed up. That's a very good strike force for very little money. Malky will then have more money to spend in other areas of the field.

No Thanks - Like a spoilt brat

Lets have someone thats going to fight to the bitter end for the club - Not some drunken tart