Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 11:26 am

Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:A player is only worth what a club is willing to pay? And don't recall lots of clubs bidding for his services, so that must tell you something about things! And not sure why fans on here are moaning about regarding the deal as it was in public domain what the contract was when sold! :thumbup:


First of all Allan, Other Clubs did not know they could pay as little as £2.5mill for Marshall, a tag of £10mill was put on him by our Cardiff City Committee.


Allan, you posted this a while back, what did you mean?



Yes but he refused several offers before to go, anyway doesn't matter what happens to him he's not a city player! :thumbup:
User avatar
pembroke allan

Posts: 11277
Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:00 pm
Location: Cardiff



1st part of question other clubs knew of our intention to sell all they had to do was make offer ! As it was only hull did,
2nd question probably to do with him being pushed or wanting to leave himself ? The rest I've no idea as it looks if taken out context or parts left out, but then no idea why your asking such things which were obviously posted at time of his sale!! :thumbup:

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 11:42 am

How much did we sell Tom Heaton for?Now there's one for debate!!

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 12:03 pm

pembroke allan wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:A player is only worth what a club is willing to pay? And don't recall lots of clubs bidding for his services, so that must tell you something about things! And not sure why fans on here are moaning about regarding the deal as it was in public domain what the contract was when sold! :thumbup:


First of all Allan, Other Clubs did not know they could pay as little as £2.5mill for Marshall, a tag of £10mill was put on him by our Cardiff City Committee.


Allan, you posted this a while back, what did you mean?



Yes but he refused several offers before to go, anyway doesn't matter what happens to him he's not a city player! :thumbup:
User avatar
pembroke allan

Posts: 11277
Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:00 pm
Location: Cardiff



1st part of question other clubs knew of our intention to sell all they had to do was make offer ! As it was only hull did,
2nd question probably to do with him being pushed or wanting to leave himself ? The rest I've no idea as it looks if taken out context or parts left out, but then no idea why your asking such things which were obviously posted at time of his sale!! :thumbup:



No parts left out by you, its exactly as u said it regarding Marshall :thumbright:

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 12:04 pm

theclaw wrote:How much did we sell Tom Heaton for?Now there's one for debate!!


We gave him away if I remember :shock:

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 1:03 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
theclaw wrote:How much did we sell Tom Heaton for?Now there's one for debate!!


We gave him away if I remember :shock:



we offered him a contract which he turned down due to lack of 1st team opportunity

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 1:12 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:A player is only worth what a club is willing to pay? And don't recall lots of clubs bidding for his services, so that must tell you something about things! And not sure why fans on here are moaning about regarding the deal as it was in public domain what the contract was when sold! :thumbup:


First of all Allan, Other Clubs did not know they could pay as little as £2.5mill for Marshall, a tag of £10mill was put on him by our Cardiff City Committee.


Allan, you posted this a while back, what did you mean?



Yes but he refused several offers before to go, anyway doesn't matter what happens to him he's not a city player! :thumbup:
User avatar
pembroke allan

Posts: 11277
Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:00 pm
Location: Cardiff



1st part of question other clubs knew of our intention to sell all they had to do was make offer ! As it was only hull did,
2nd question probably to do with him being pushed or wanting to leave himself ? The rest I've no idea as it looks if taken out context or parts left out, but then no idea why your asking such things which were obviously posted at time of his sale!! :thumbup:



No parts left out by you, its exactly as u said it regarding Marshall :thumbright:



So what's your point ? As in isolation it means sfa to me other than it obviously refers to marshall? I was obviously answering another post from someone ? Anyway who cares about something
Said months ago very weired :thumbup:

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 1:15 pm

pembroke allan wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:A player is only worth what a club is willing to pay? And don't recall lots of clubs bidding for his services, so that must tell you something about things! And not sure why fans on here are moaning about regarding the deal as it was in public domain what the contract was when sold! :thumbup:


First of all Allan, Other Clubs did not know they could pay as little as £2.5mill for Marshall, a tag of £10mill was put on him by our Cardiff City Committee.


Allan, you posted this a while back, what did you mean?



Yes but he refused several offers before to go, anyway doesn't matter what happens to him he's not a city player! :thumbup:
User avatar
pembroke allan

Posts: 11277
Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:00 pm
Location: Cardiff



1st part of question other clubs knew of our intention to sell all they had to do was make offer ! As it was only hull did,
2nd question probably to do with him being pushed or wanting to leave himself ? The rest I've no idea as it looks if taken out context or parts left out, but then no idea why your asking such things which were obviously posted at time of his sale!! :thumbup:



No parts left out by you, its exactly as u said it regarding Marshall :thumbright:



So what's your point ? As in isolation it means sfa to me other than it obviously refers to marshall? I was obviously answering another post from someone ? Anyway who cares :thumbup:



My point Allan is, you stated Marshall refused other offers back then, yet now your saying No other clubs wanted him ? ?

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 1:46 pm

if we were trying to move Marshall on. every club would have been made aware of that either through our club or through the players agent { who had quite a bit to gain }.

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 3:53 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:A player is only worth what a club is willing to pay? And don't recall lots of clubs bidding for his services, so that must tell you something about things! And not sure why fans on here are moaning about regarding the deal as it was in public domain what the contract was when sold! :thumbup:


First of all Allan, Other Clubs did not know they could pay as little as £2.5mill for Marshall, a tag of £10mill was put on him by our Cardiff City Committee.


Allan, you posted this a while back, what did you mean?



Yes but he refused several offers before to go, anyway doesn't matter what happens to him he's not a city player! :thumbup:
User avatar
pembroke allan

Posts: 11277
Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:00 pm
Location: Cardiff



1st part of question other clubs knew of our intention to sell all they had to do was make offer ! As it was only hull did,
2nd question probably to do with him being pushed or wanting to leave himself ? The rest I've no idea as it looks if taken out context or parts left out, but then no idea why your asking such things which were obviously posted at time of his sale!! :thumbup:



No parts left out by you, its exactly as u said it regarding Marshall :thumbright:



So what's your point ? As in isolation it means sfa to me other than it obviously refers to marshall? I was obviously answering another post from someone ? Anyway who cares :thumbup:



My point Allan is, you stated Marshall refused other offers back then, yet now your saying No other clubs wanted him ? ?



Do I hear the penny dropping?
Game, set and match Annis!

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 4:06 pm

Again how bad is our Club run !! Marshall was worth ten mill not long ago and in the end we sold for 2.5 million. And then panicked and had Amos on loan at an absalute fortune and was a failure. :? :?: :o

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 4:29 pm

Nuclearblue wrote:Again how bad is our Club run !! Marshall was worth ten mill not long ago and in the end we sold for 2.5 million. And then panicked and had Amos on loan at an absalute fortune and was a failure. :? :?: :o

10 million :lol: come on ffs

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Mon May 15, 2017 4:35 pm

Nuclearblue wrote:Again how bad is our Club run !! Marshall was worth ten mill not long ago and in the end we sold for 2.5 million. And then panicked and had Amos on loan at an absalute fortune and was a failure. :? :?: :o



10mill was the stated price but was there any real offer?. very often a large sum is mentioned to make a point more than it being the actual price as with Zohore.
personally i think he has failed missrably this year and 2.5 mill seems tip top business if it hadnt been for the Amos thing working out so poorly

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Thu May 18, 2017 12:25 pm

Nuclearblue wrote:Again how bad is our Club run !! Marshall was worth ten mill not long ago and in the end we sold for 2.5 million. And then panicked and had Amos on loan at an absalute fortune and was a failure. :? :?: :o


His form dipped and his price went down although I don't think anyone was ever looking seriously at him at that price. When we went down I said we should have sold him if we could get 5m but got shouted down.

Amos was a failure but hull fans are saying the same about Marshall.

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Fri May 19, 2017 6:17 am

Woodville Willie wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:A player is only worth what a club is willing to pay? And don't recall lots of clubs bidding for his services, so that must tell you something about things! And not sure why fans on here are moaning about regarding the deal as it was in public domain what the contract was when sold! :thumbup:


First of all Allan, Other Clubs did not know they could pay as little as £2.5mill for Marshall, a tag of £10mill was put on him by our Cardiff City Committee.


Allan, you posted this a while back, what did you mean?



Yes but he refused several offers before to go, anyway doesn't matter what happens to him he's not a city player! :thumbup:
User avatar
pembroke allan

Posts: 11277
Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:00 pm
Location: Cardiff



1st part of question other clubs knew of our intention to sell all they had to do was make offer ! As it was only hull did,
2nd question probably to do with him being pushed or wanting to leave himself ? The rest I've no idea as it looks if taken out context or parts left out, but then no idea why your asking such things which were obviously posted at time of his sale!! :thumbup:



No parts left out by you, its exactly as u said it regarding Marshall :thumbright:



So what's your point ? As in isolation it means sfa to me other than it obviously refers to marshall? I was obviously answering another post from someone ? Anyway who cares :thumbup:



My point Allan is, you stated Marshall refused other offers back then, yet now your saying No other clubs wanted him ? ?



Do I hear the penny dropping?
Game, set and match Annis!


:lol:
He's given up as usual. He'll argue black is blue and then disappear.

Re: " Cardiff City lose out on £2.5mill "

Sat May 20, 2017 10:34 pm

:shock: