A forum for all things Cardiff City
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:16 pm
If we are looking at a defensive option and try to quell Liverpool from midfield then I think we would go with :
...............Heaton
McNaughton Gerrard Turner Taylor
...............Whitts
...........Gunnarsson Kiss
..Cowie.....................Mason
................Miller
Or if we are going more attack minded then maybe :
...............Heaton
McNaughton Gerrard Turner Taylor
...............McPhail
...........Gunnarsson Whitts
..Cowie........................Mason
................Miller
What do you think Malky will do ?
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:17 pm
Mcphail has to play if fit IMO.
I'd also replace Mason in both teams for conway
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:18 pm
----------------Heaton
McNaughton - Blake - Turner - Taylor
Cowie - Gunnarsson - Whitts - Mason - Conway
----------------Miller
---------------------------------------------------------
Subs, Marshall, Gerrard or Hudson, Ralls, Earnshaw, Kiss, Gestede & McPhail.
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:23 pm
2blue2handle wrote:Mcphail has to play if fit IMO.
I'd also replace Mason in both teams for conway
I reckon Mason could be the surprise in the team that Liverpool may not know about.
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:23 pm
Overthemoon wrote:----------------Heaton
McNaughton - Blake - Turner - Taylor
Cowie - Gunnarsson - Whitts - Mason - Conway
----------------Miller
---------------------------------------------------------
Subs, Marshall, Gerrard or Hudson, Ralls, Earnshaw, Kiss, Gestede & McPhail.
You think Malky will play Blake ahead of Hudson or Gerrard ?
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:25 pm
Heaton
MacNaughton
Hudson
Turner
Taylor
Kiss
McPhail
Whittingham
Gunnarson
Cowie
Miller
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:27 pm
Overthemoon wrote:----------------Heaton
McNaughton - Blake - Turner - Taylor
Cowie - Gunnarsson - Whitts - Mason - Conway
----------------Miller
---------------------------------------------------------
Subs, Marshall, Gerrard or Hudson, Ralls, Earnshaw, Kiss, Gestede & McPhail.
i like this one
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:27 pm
Overthemoon wrote:----------------Heaton
McNaughton - Blake - Turner - Taylor
Cowie - Gunnarsson - Whitts - Mason - Conway
----------------Miller
---------------------------------------------------------
Subs, Marshall, Gerrard or Hudson, Ralls, Earnshaw, Kiss, Gestede & McPhail.
i like this one
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:28 pm
carlccfc wrote:Overthemoon wrote:----------------Heaton
McNaughton - Blake - Turner - Taylor
Cowie - Gunnarsson - Whitts - Mason - Conway
----------------Miller
---------------------------------------------------------
Subs, Marshall, Gerrard or Hudson, Ralls, Earnshaw, Kiss, Gestede & McPhail.
You think Malky will play Blake ahead of Hudson or Gerrard ?
It's not that I think Malky will start with Darcy, just that I would, for the following reasons:-
Although I thought Gerrard was playing slightly better than Hudson when Turner came into the side and was unlucky to have been dropped, Gerrard's performances have been decidedly average at best, since Hudson got injured!
I'd therefore play Darcy alongside Turner, as Wembley is a big pitch and with Hudson just coming back from several weeks out, I think he'd struggle!
I know Darcy has his failings and that his distribution is poor on occasion (As well as McNaughton btw), but I think that Darcy's pace could be very effective in combatting Liverpool's pacey frontline of Suarez, Bellamy, Downing and possibly Kuyt!
We'd lose a bit of height with Darcy in the side and Carroll could cause us problems should he play, but I think Darcy's pace would be more beneficial than height on such a big pitch!
Darcy's also played there and marked Rooney out of the match for 90 minutes fairly recently and I'd therefore start with him!
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:44 pm
heaton
mcnaughton - gerrard - turner - taylor
cowie - gunnarson - mcphail - whitts - conway
miller
this is what i think malky will go with. Maybe if he wishes to really go for it mason will play ahead of mcphail just infront of the midfield four/just behind miller which is a role he plays extremely well. if hudson is 100 % i think he will start too.
Thu Feb 23, 2012 8:46 pm
From the horses mouth - Hudson - im fit , McPhail ive no chance
Thu Feb 23, 2012 9:05 pm
Personally i wouldnt play any of the young'ns, Mason or Ralls. Too big of an occasion i think
Would also LOVE Macca to be fit and ready to play, but can't really see it happening
he deserves another wembley game!
Thu Feb 23, 2012 9:09 pm
TBH I think Malky will go for an experienced striker up front and if he gets tired he will replace him with another experienced striker whom Liverpool will not be expecting to see. Robert Earnshaw. Malky will try and get the team more defensive minded than attacking minded but will train them to hit them on the break. Once we're on the run, don't stop until we score. Similar to West Ham
__________________________________________Heaton_______________________________________
McNaughton_________________Hudson (Gerrard)__________Turner_________________________Taylor
_______________________________________McPhail (Kiss)_____________________________________
Cowie____________________Gunnarsson___________________Whittingham________________Conway
_____________________________________Miller (Earnshaw)____________________________________
Thu Feb 23, 2012 9:10 pm
Blackpool Blues wrote:From the horses mouth - Hudson - im fit , McPhail ive no chance
Youre fit? Get in the there then!
Thu Feb 23, 2012 9:18 pm
Has to be:
-----------------------Heaton-----------------------
Mcnaughton---Hudson-----Turner-------Taylor
-------------------------------------------------------
--------------------Whittingham--------------------
Cowie-----Gunnarsson-------------------Conway
--------------------------------Mason---------------
-------------------Miller-----------------------------
Assuming everyone is fit!
Thu Feb 23, 2012 9:59 pm
Cant see Hudson starting to be honest, but I think he (& McPhail) will make the bench
Thu Feb 23, 2012 10:24 pm
NickPenarth wrote:Cant see Hudson starting to be honest, but I think he (& McPhail) will make the bench
im going with you on this, depending on whether darcy will play instead of gerrard.
Thu Feb 23, 2012 10:49 pm
Should go with...
--------------------------Heaton------------------------
-----McNaughton---Hudson---Turner---Taylor-------
--------------------------McPhail------------------------
---Cowie---Whittingham---Gunnarsson--Conway---
---------------------------Miller---------------------------
Or
--------------------------Heaton------------------------
-----McNaughton---Hudson---Turner---Taylor-------
---Cowie---Whittingham---Gunnarsson--Conway---
--------------------------Mason-------------------------
--------------------------Miller--------------------------
Which would you prefer?! I'm undecided
Thu Feb 23, 2012 11:31 pm
If Macca is fit:
.........Heaton
Kev...Huds...Turner...Taylor
...........Macca
......Gunnar..Whitts
Cowie..................Conway
............Miller
SUBS: Marshall, Blake, Gerrard, Kiss, Mason, Gestede, Earnie
If he isnt fit:
..........Heaton
Kev...Huds...Turner...Taylor
.......Whitts..Gunnar
Cowie.................Conway
............Mason
............Miller
SUBS: Marshall, Blake, Gerrard, Kiss, Harris, Earnie, Gestede
The first team will give us a better chance IMO. We need to control the midfield
Fri Feb 24, 2012 12:35 am
If everyone is fit and available for selection:
-----------------------Heaton-----------------------
Mcnaughton---Hudson-----Turner-------Taylor
-------------------------------------------------------
--------------------Mcphail--------------------
Cowie---Gunnarsson---Whittingham---Conway
-----------------------------------------------
-------------------Miller-----------------------------
Subs: Marshall, Blake, Gerrard, Kiss, Mason, Gestede, Earnshaw---------Sorry Ralls!
Fri Feb 24, 2012 10:53 am
Is it only me that thinks Rudy will need to play inorder to boost our set piece chances? Realistically, it is our best chance of grabbing a goal or two!
Fri Feb 24, 2012 11:16 am
One of:
or
The first one more likely. I can't see MM putting Mason on a wing he's had chances to do it before be always put him centrally.
Fri Feb 24, 2012 12:01 pm
Heaton
Blake Turner. -----------------------------------
Mcnaughton. Taylor-----------------------------
Gunnarson. captain- Mcphail
Cowie Conway
Whittingham
Gestade
Miller. subs...Mason. Gerrard Hudson
Fri Feb 24, 2012 3:21 pm
Whatever the team is, I think this is going to be a much closer game than certain people and sections of the media are expecting.
If we can keep it tight until around the hour mark then the game will open up and we'll have a real chance.
I'm not one for posting line-ups and predictions, but that's mine, for what it's worth.
Fri Feb 24, 2012 4:29 pm
bluebirds949 wrote:Overthemoon wrote:----------------Heaton
McNaughton - Blake - Turner - Taylor
Cowie - Gunnarsson - Whitts - Mason - Conway
----------------Miller
---------------------------------------------------------
Subs, Marshall, Gerrard or Hudson, Ralls, Earnshaw, Kiss, Gestede & McPhail.
i like this one
this
Fri Feb 24, 2012 7:13 pm
Just wondering if we we have Rose tinted glasses on when it come to super kev? Let's be honest, and I think he was brilliant last season, but has been somewhat poor this year and has been our week link, should we just drop farcy in at right back?
Fri Feb 24, 2012 7:14 pm
bluebirds949 wrote:Overthemoon wrote:----------------Heaton
McNaughton - Blake - Turner - Taylor
Cowie - Gunnarsson - Whitts - Mason - Conway
----------------Miller
---------------------------------------------------------
Subs, Marshall, Gerrard or Hudson, Ralls, Earnshaw, Kiss, Gestede & McPhail.
i like this one
Fri Feb 24, 2012 7:52 pm
Anyone but Kiss !
I think he's a bit like the emperors new clothes, because what others see in him I cant !
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group.
phpBB Mobile / SEO by Artodia.