mjw6150 wrote:You'd think we would get an exception considering our circumstances and that we are not a team they are trying to capture in this rule
oohahhPaulMillar wrote:Do even the big Premier league clubs loan 8 players to “foreign” teams each season
I wouldn’t have thought so
Wayne S wrote:Would they allow us in the Welsh Cup if we gave up the English FA Cup?
Only fair that we do.
Spot on. As much as it sounds great we need to stay clear of the Welsh Cup to avoid being kicked out of the system all together. It's a grey area that will somehow be resolved just a pain at the moment.mjw6150 wrote:Wayne S wrote:Would they allow us in the Welsh Cup if we gave up the English FA Cup?
Only fair that we do.
That sounds great but problem will be it may set a precedent where people say, 'why don't you join the welsh league as well then' and we need to avoid that at all costs!
mjw6150 wrote:Wayne S wrote:Would they allow us in the Welsh Cup if we gave up the English FA Cup?
Only fair that we do.
That sounds great but problem will be it may set a precedent where people say, 'why don't you join the welsh league as well then' and we need to avoid that at all costs!
Tonteg Bluebird wrote:What about the rules for Berwick Rangers? They play in the Scottish league but they're based in England.
What are the rules for New Saints? They're in the Welsh league but their ground is in Oswestry, England.
We need to investigate if the rules apply for other clubs playing in a league belonging to one country, but situated in another country.
Do English clubs loaning players to Berwick Rangers count as a foreign loan as they're in the Scottish league, or are the FA just picking on the Welsh clubs in the English pyramid, so these rules just apply to Cardiff, Swansea, Newport and Wrexham?
We need to investigate, but whether the rules are consistent to apply to Berwick Rangers or not, these rules are definitely not fair.
All Welsh clubs need to unite together to challenge this.
Welshman in CA wrote:Tonteg Bluebird wrote:What about the rules for Berwick Rangers? They play in the Scottish league but they're based in England.
What are the rules for New Saints? They're in the Welsh league but their ground is in Oswestry, England.
We need to investigate if the rules apply for other clubs playing in a league belonging to one country, but situated in another country.
Do English clubs loaning players to Berwick Rangers count as a foreign loan as they're in the Scottish league, or are the FA just picking on the Welsh clubs in the English pyramid, so these rules just apply to Cardiff, Swansea, Newport and Wrexham?
We need to investigate, but whether the rules are consistent to apply to Berwick Rangers or not, these rules are definitely not fair.
All Welsh clubs need to unite together to challenge this.
Not sure how the FA could be picking on Welsh clubs when it's a new FIFA rule being discussed but you go ahead & blame the English FA for it.
Tonteg Bluebird wrote:Welshman in CA wrote:Tonteg Bluebird wrote:What about the rules for Berwick Rangers? They play in the Scottish league but they're based in England.
What are the rules for New Saints? They're in the Welsh league but their ground is in Oswestry, England.
We need to investigate if the rules apply for other clubs playing in a league belonging to one country, but situated in another country.
Do English clubs loaning players to Berwick Rangers count as a foreign loan as they're in the Scottish league, or are the FA just picking on the Welsh clubs in the English pyramid, so these rules just apply to Cardiff, Swansea, Newport and Wrexham?
We need to investigate, but whether the rules are consistent to apply to Berwick Rangers or not, these rules are definitely not fair.
All Welsh clubs need to unite together to challenge this.
Not sure how the FA could be picking on Welsh clubs when it's a new FIFA rule being discussed but you go ahead & blame the English FA for it.
I obviously meant FIFA, not the FA, but you just pick me up on that mistype and ignore all the other points I've made.
Users browsing this forum: Bytespider [Bot], City1983, Clusterman, DotBot [Bot], Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot], Grapeshot [Bot], ias [Bot], Proximic [Bot], Underhill1927, Verity [Bot] and 240 guests