Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 8:07 am

taffyapple wrote:
thomasblue wrote:I chose players on who i believe are the best in there positions consistently not over a few months ,
Friend i dont know much about so would need to see him more to have an opinion .Just because you like him doesnt mean he would make my top 5 .
Murray has had a good season but like said a lot of penaltys . Chris woods is promising but needs to do it over a few more months not just a scoring spurt .
I didnt show myself up i said taylor is not the best FULLBACK in the league and he is far from it we just had a difference of opinion which is aloud in forum is it not ? .
Vydra looks quality fair play but others again have done it consistently , yes a lot of the players are household names but thats because they have been really good players for a few years not just half a season .
I dont use stat sites its an opinion i have made on my own by watching EVERY cardiff game LIVE not on tv home and a lot away . Also see most championship games on tv and take an interest in them is that a crime ?
You can laugh at kevin davies but he has allways won praise for performances even at prem level let alone championship by EX PROS not just people on a forum . Hes an England international and at 33 made over 500 prem league appearances he is quality and deserves a place in the top 5 imo .


Most Championship games on TV show 2-3 minutes tops. just the goals in fact.
How have you appraised the performances of so many players by watching that
show??

Your talking shite.

your going off stats


Im guessing they havnt got sky sports wherever u come from ?
I watch championship games regularly most of them in fact that are shown live and a few that are streamed if city are not playing . i dont need to quote off stat sheets to make my opinions on players and i dont need to explain my choices to a cock like you who just likes trying to put people down.
If i want to post a thread on here i will if you dont like the choices i made dont reply simple ! or is your life so boring you feel the need to try and make yourself feel better by ATTEMPTING to abuse somebodys knowledge of football which im pretty certain is a lot better than yours . if i went off stat sheets my list would be pretty easy to find elsewhere wouldnt it ?
go fetch doggy try prove me wrong !theres a good boy .
Every player i named is quality FACT
Taylor is average championship FACT
im guessing you would have every cardiff player in there because YOU obviously dont watch other teams and just go from what papers say . Your boring me now zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 8:16 am

right, i cant find any Derby county matches that were shown live on sky from August to November, did you go to the away game up there? because i did and will hughes was ok, but didnt stand out as something special. At the most, you can only really have seen him play maybe 3 times so you are clearly basing your opinion on the words of others :roll:


why is it one rule for him, and another for someone like Wood, who has only done it for "a couple of months" :lol:

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 8:41 am

paulh_85 wrote:right, i cant find any Derby county matches that were shown live on sky from August to November, did you go to the away game up there? because i did and will hughes was ok, but didnt stand out as something special. At the most, you can only really have seen him play maybe 3 times so you are clearly basing your opinion on the words of others :roll:


why is it one rule for him, and another for someone like Wood, who has only done it for "a couple of months" :lol:


If you think wood deserves to be in there that is your opinion i have seen enough of hughes to think he is a special player and i wanted to include him in mine . end of discussion .
Thats based on seeing him live , on tv and highlights .

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 8:49 am

:lol:

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 9:01 am

Anyone who puts FACT after a sentence cannot possibly be wrong

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 9:50 am

paulh_85 wrote::lol:


How many times you seen wood play ?
Seeing as hes been loaned out 6 times in 3 years he obviously aint that good

1goal in 21 games for west brom
0 in 7 for barnsley loan
8 in 29 for brighton loan
9 in 23 for brum loan
3 in 19 for bristol loan
11 in 19 for millwall loan
5 in 3 so far for leicester loan and buy

not exactly prolific is he its only this year he has started scoring . Still a lot to prove in my opinion but is a good player

Now that was using stats :lol:

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 9:52 am

thomasblue wrote:Seeing as hes been loaned out 6 times in 3 years he obviously aint that good
:



or dear...... :laughing5:

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 10:09 am

paulh_85 wrote:
thomasblue wrote:Seeing as hes been loaned out 6 times in 3 years he obviously aint that good
:



or dear...... :laughing5:


Were not going to agree , west brom obviously didnt think much of him .
Compare him with charlie austin 173 goals in 264 games
a goal every 1.5 games compared to woods 3.5 speaks for itself really dont it .

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 10:29 am

not really. Austin scored a lot of goals in league 1.

wood is younger, never really given much of a chance at west brom, but obviously he hasnt done it on a consistant level as he hasnt had the chance.


But then neither has Will Hughes :laughing6:

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 10:30 am

should add that i would prefer austin to Wood

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 10:40 am

paulh_85 wrote:should add that i would prefer austin to Wood


I wouldnt argue against his potential just need to see him do it more consistently over the rest of this season and next to put him in with the best strikers in the league .
Will hughes just has really impressed me and i really think he is a special player , a lot like ramsey was with us . Even after 20 odd games you could see ramsey was above this league i get the same impression with hughes .
He is also quite slow but his positioning is good which makes up for his lack of pace

Re: Best championship players

Mon Jan 21, 2013 11:03 am

Dont watch other clubs week in and week out, and football league show shows about 2 mins of a 90min game so cant go off that.

But from what ive seen, i think kasper Schmeichel is a cracking keeper, finally seems to have a settled back 4 in front of him and think it shows.

Also dont see what the world sees in Zaha, think hes a kick and run player, wouldnt know a trick if he was in the magic circle, and think he will be found out as another SWP in the prem.

Like everyone says Chris Wood seems the business in this league, but will he cut it consistently in the prem, or could we or another newly promoted team afford him the time to get consistent in the Prem??

Think in the championship, johnnie jackson at charlton is massively underrated. With another couple of yards of pace would be a prem player for sure.