Thu Aug 22, 2024 9:53 am
Thu Aug 22, 2024 10:00 am
Thu Aug 22, 2024 11:26 am
Thu Aug 22, 2024 11:35 am
llan bluebird wrote:I rate King but where is he in Buluts depth chart
1 Rambo
2 Ralls
3 Siopis
4 Robertson
5 Turnbull
6 Rinomhota/Wintle (if one doesn't leave)
A loan to Christmas seems the best idea and maybe we get a premier league loan in as well.
Thu Aug 22, 2024 11:38 am
Flashman wrote:This is an absolute disgrace,a guy that was very highly thought of in Scotland last year yet is given no opportunity to stake his claim with the City, Bulut has no intention whatsoever of giving any of our young players a whiff of a chance, I’m fed up of hearing his misleading statements about how promising our youngsters are, then effectively sidelining every one of them.
Thu Aug 22, 2024 11:54 am
Forever Blue wrote:llan bluebird wrote:I rate King but where is he in Buluts depth chart
1 Rambo
2 Ralls
3 Siopis
4 Robertson
5 Turnbull
6 Rinomhota/Wintle (if one doesn't leave)
A loan to Christmas seems the best idea and maybe we get a premier league loan in as well.
Really?
If Eli King is good enough, then it’s now.
He will be 22 yrs old.
Continue with Dads army and we will go down.
I will say it again in 14 years not one player from sending them continues out on loan has ever come back to make it a Fact.
Thu Aug 22, 2024 12:38 pm
llan bluebird wrote:Forever Blue wrote:llan bluebird wrote:I rate King but where is he in Buluts depth chart
1 Rambo
2 Ralls
3 Siopis
4 Robertson
5 Turnbull
6 Rinomhota/Wintle (if one doesn't leave)
A loan to Christmas seems the best idea and maybe we get a premier league loan in as well.
Really?
If Eli King is good enough, then it’s now.
He will be 22 yrs old.
Continue with Dads army and we will go down.
I will say it again in 14 years not one player from sending them continues out on loan has ever come back to make it a Fact.
My gut tells me that either Rinomhota or Wintle will be staying or we will have to take double hits on them. The fact that 2 peak-aged Championship CM's are still here tells me we pay very well......
Regarding kids on loan, Ralls and McGuiness came back much better players but there are not many I agree.
The problem is the top academies steal any potential at schoolboy level, and hoard players with only a minuscule number ever getting anywhere near their first-team squad. Then there is a whole industry within the club organising loans to show off their product like cattle. letting them go relatively cheaply but with large just-in-case sell-on and return clauses. 99% of Arsenal fans have never heard of Mark McGuiness but are happy for the two million.
If King has a good early season and we have injuries, we get him back match fit, if we are doing well we could sell him to L1 clubs who need a boost. If he can't make the grade we have messed up again.
The club is a mess, we all agree we need a DOF but Tan doesn't think he needs one, nuts in todays world.
Thu Aug 22, 2024 1:06 pm
Forever Blue wrote:llan bluebird wrote:Forever Blue wrote:llan bluebird wrote:I rate King but where is he in Buluts depth chart
1 Rambo
2 Ralls
3 Siopis
4 Robertson
5 Turnbull
6 Rinomhota/Wintle (if one doesn't leave)
A loan to Christmas seems the best idea and maybe we get a premier league loan in as well.
Really?
If Eli King is good enough, then it’s now.
He will be 22 yrs old.
Continue with Dads army and we will go down.
I will say it again in 14 years not one player from sending them continues out on loan has ever come back to make it a Fact.
My gut tells me that either Rinomhota or Wintle will be staying or we will have to take double hits on them. The fact that 2 peak-aged Championship CM's are still here tells me we pay very well......
Regarding kids on loan, Ralls and McGuiness came back much better players but there are not many I agree.
The problem is the top academies steal any potential at schoolboy level, and hoard players with only a minuscule number ever getting anywhere near their first-team squad. Then there is a whole industry within the club organising loans to show off their product like cattle. letting them go relatively cheaply but with large just-in-case sell-on and return clauses. 99% of Arsenal fans have never heard of Mark McGuiness but are happy for the two million.
If King has a good early season and we have injuries, we get him back match fit, if we are doing well we could sell him to L1 clubs who need a boost. If he can't make the grade we have messed up again.
The club is a mess, we all agree we need a DOF but Tan doesn't think he needs one, nuts in todays world.
Sorry I meant the players who have come trough our Academy?
As to McGuinness he went out to a Big Club Sheffield Wednesday going for promotion, a put we did not send our Accademy players to clubs like that.
Thu Aug 22, 2024 1:26 pm
worcester_ccfc wrote:Still not convinced he’s good enough for the Championship.
Doing well in League Two and Scotland is not the same as doing well in this league.
But I see know sense in loaning him out yet again. He’s either good enough for the Championship or not.
If he isn’t, just let him go permanently.
Thu Aug 22, 2024 4:07 pm
llan bluebird wrote:Forever Blue wrote:llan bluebird wrote:Forever Blue wrote:llan bluebird wrote:I rate King but where is he in Buluts depth chart
1 Rambo
2 Ralls
3 Siopis
4 Robertson
5 Turnbull
6 Rinomhota/Wintle (if one doesn't leave)
A loan to Christmas seems the best idea and maybe we get a premier league loan in as well.
Really?
If Eli King is good enough, then it’s now.
He will be 22 yrs old.
Continue with Dads army and we will go down.
I will say it again in 14 years not one player from sending them continues out on loan has ever come back to make it a Fact.
My gut tells me that either Rinomhota or Wintle will be staying or we will have to take double hits on them. The fact that 2 peak-aged Championship CM's are still here tells me we pay very well......
Regarding kids on loan, Ralls and McGuiness came back much better players but there are not many I agree.
The problem is the top academies steal any potential at schoolboy level, and hoard players with only a minuscule number ever getting anywhere near their first-team squad. Then there is a whole industry within the club organising loans to show off their product like cattle. letting them go relatively cheaply but with large just-in-case sell-on and return clauses. 99% of Arsenal fans have never heard of Mark McGuiness but are happy for the two million.
If King has a good early season and we have injuries, we get him back match fit, if we are doing well we could sell him to L1 clubs who need a boost. If he can't make the grade we have messed up again.
The club is a mess, we all agree we need a DOF but Tan doesn't think he needs one, nuts in todays world.
Sorry I meant the players who have come trough our Academy?
As to McGuinness he went out to a Big Club Sheffield Wednesday going for promotion, a put we did not send our Accademy players to clubs like that.
Its only just dawned on me why the club does not go to great (any) lengths to publish youth games, it keeps the big clubs scouts away. It may just be we are poor, you never know with us.
Back to King, I think if we keep Rinomhota on decent bucks we need to play him so its easier to send Eli out for four months
Thu Aug 22, 2024 5:57 pm
Thu Aug 22, 2024 6:44 pm
Thu Aug 22, 2024 8:12 pm
Fri Aug 23, 2024 10:51 pm
Sat Aug 24, 2024 7:17 am
EastleighBlue wrote:I am in a minority but I think he's made the right call. King offered little in pre season games or in the recent cup game to suggest he'd have an impact on the first team or in the Championship this year. As for Dad's army? We've just signed three players in their early twenties. Things will change. Are the academy players good enough? No, is probably the answer but that's the fault of Purse and the club hierarchy not Bulut
Sat Aug 24, 2024 1:35 pm