Red card - yes or no?

We would have been upset if the roles were reversed & their player stayed on the pitch.

Exactly, that's why I say it's a red card.

We would have been upset if the roles were reversed & their player stayed on the pitch.

Exactly, that's why I say it's a red card.

red card if you're the away side, yellow if home

Not even a foul, let alone a card. Two players coming together, neither player won it. Play on.

We would have been upset if the roles were reversed & their player stayed on the pitch.

Exactly, that's why I say it's a red card.

That applies to every decision that is debatable? Saw it last night and was s coming together and as said he was not in control of ball so not even certain he would got shot off before o'dowda reached him..... denying goal scoring opportunity even covers 50yds to goal as red card was given yesterday in that scenario.. at least only one match ban..

Another poor decision by ref in championship.... Watford given penalty after goalie dives out to collect ball but just as goes to clutch it watford player stretched leg out touched ball past goalie but of course his momentum takes him forward where ball was so ref gives pen! Now watford 2-0 up 25mins

that was a 50 50 at best I've watched it back many times and they both put a foot in at the same time and goutas was shoved off the ball before the player even touched it, their player didn't even have possession, it was two players clashing for the same ball 50 50 no foul no red

I watched the first half then went out for the rugby, I was really surprised when i saw the highlights this morning that thats was the reason for the sending-off. On the train i saw Red Card Last Man pop up on my phone, so was expecting a Gabor Gyepes tackle not a 50/50 challenge for the ball

Real home decision

I watched it several times and has been said already there appeared to be a push in the back of a City player trying to head the ball on the half way line before it was punted downfield for Goutas and their forward to run on to. It looks to me as though the Plymouth player moves his body into Goutas as they are running causing a collision and conning the ref into issuing a red card. O'Dowda was quite close to them both whether he would have got across to dispossess their forward I am not sure ,but I do think it was a dubious decision.

51% no 49% yes so probably not but I can see why it was given, we were unlucky again.