Sat May 28, 2016 10:28 am
Jupiter wrote:How can you say the House of Lords is "great"? They are unelected!
The whole problem with the UK system is that it is "elitist".
Additionally the Media influence political sway, they are also unelected.
As for the House of Commons it is a Public School play ground.
The House of Commons should work on the premise of local communities suggesting local candidates to the parties. It doesn't work this way, the parties suggest candidates to the local communities. This is not "real" democracy.
"Real democracy" starts with the local communities - a bottom up approach, not a top down approach.
I'm all for more referendums - Swiss style democracy. This way the people get a say more often.
This referendum is good because it gets people thinking about politics. Although I am for "staying in the EU", I think that some good points for "exit" have been raised on this forum.
Sat May 28, 2016 10:43 am
Sat May 28, 2016 11:10 am
Jupiter wrote:This validates my point. Read my message again.
- The ratio of politicians that are public school is a higher percentage of the population than are not. This is elitist.
- The local community can only vote on the chosen candidates. My point was they should be more involved in proposing them.
I am a believer in equal opportunity, not necessarily equal outcome. Quality free education should be a right for all, including up to University level.
Dennis Skinner would agree with me on this. He attended Ruskin College in Oxford whose very purpose was to provide education for those from backgrounds with limited resources.
Sat May 28, 2016 11:24 am
Sat May 28, 2016 11:40 am
castleblue wrote:Sneggyblubird wrote:castleblue wrote:Nuclearblue wrote:AfricanBluebird wrote:I am completely in favour of staying in the EU, however that is not to say I don't think it needs overhauling in certain areas.
In terms of leaving I just don't think we understand the ramifications of it - there has been so little 'facts' based research on short, medium and long term ramifications. In the absence of this research people are very 'emotionally' motivated about leaving rather than making a considered decision.
Having a referendum at this stage is nonsense and there should have been much more consultation and research.
Now that is the problem Chief you can't overhaul something that isn't a democracy and is run like a communist style dictatorship. Cameron tried to overhaul it didn't he ? What happened there ? Yeah they took the piss out of him and he came away with jack shit and believe me he had leverage.
What I don't understand is that most don't realise it isn't democratic and you can't change or even attempt to change the EU laws.
In principle the EU is a good idea but it's ruined by by power hungry Marxist style dictators running the show.
In the world more country's ain't in the EU and do just fine.
I agree with most of that Nukes, Marxist dictators would probably be MORE democratic than this lot, and that for me is the biggest reason for voting leave, the ABSOLUTE undemocratic nature of the political system of the EU. I voted in the last referendum after the Harold Wilson government attempted to renegotiate the terms of membership. Since the Margaret Thatcher, Major, Blair, Brown and now Cameron have tried to either renegotiate or get agreement on the overhaul of the non democratic political system of the EU. Still our politicians say "Well it isn't perfect but we are better off inside trying to change the EU". BOLLOCKS it will NEVER change whilst the main "Council Of The EU" , the body that negotiates and implements EU Law is made up of non elected political appointments. In my opinion not since the "Doges of Venice" has there been such an undemocratic system of government but one after another our political leaders have shown a complete lack of desire to deal with this. It's UNBELIEVEABLE.
There are many examples of where the law created by this unelected "Council Of The EU" have had a negative effect on the UK and, in my opinion, the biggest relates to the "Free Movement Of Labour". This gives ABSOLUTE freedom for the migration of people across the EU and we now know that as a result the population of the UK has increased by over 2m in the last 5 years.
Unfortunately the LEAVE campaign continually talk about IMMIGRATION in relation to this issue, but immigration means the movement of people across International borders, a process where the UK still has complete control, whist migration means the movement of people within the borders of a single state, a process over which the UK has ABSOLUTELY NO CONTROL thanks to EU law so when people like Nigel Farage say we have lost of our borders he is only saying the truth. For that he is dubbed a racist. Unbelieveable.
Blair had the power to VETO this but he didn't and Cameron talks about us being outside the "Schengen" zone and claims as a result we still control our borders, A LIE, but still people are not waking up to the problems that are ahead of us if we do not get control of our borders back.
Almost ALL areas of our society are being put under pressure because of the level of uncontrolled migration into this country, housing, education, health, transport and employment are suffering and the only way to correct this is to get back control of our borders. To do this we need to exit the EU and as soon as possible.
I am not a racist and I honestly believe that controlled immigration has in the past, is today and will be in the future a massive positive for the UK and absolutely must continue. What has to STOP is the uncontrolled mass migration of people across the EU.
Vote leave and lets get back to the great democratic political system we enjoyed prior to joining this nutcase undemocratic EU we were mad enough to join over 40 years ago.
I wonder if either you or nuclear blue could actually tell us how the EU works without having to rescherch it first.Last time I looked we had our own unelected body which has been responsible for many changes to government proposed law and when all things are considered haven't done a bad job.
Having the House of Lords review legislation is one of the things that makes our political system great although I accept your point that nowadays there are so many political appoints that it can look like an institution created by vested interest.But the main LAW making body of this country remains the House of Commons and that is a directly elected democratic body.
Can you seriously claim that the Council of the EU is the same as the House Of Lords.
Sat May 28, 2016 11:46 am
Sat May 28, 2016 11:59 am
ninianboy wrote:From a Welsh perspective we have to vote to remain in the EU.
If we leave then an Eton dominated parliament at Westminster will crush any notion of Welsh identity, economic needs, and ambition.
Don't go along with Sun reading English bigots - stand up for Wales!
Sat May 28, 2016 1:06 pm
ninianboy wrote:From a Welsh perspective we have to vote to remain in the EU.
If we leave then an Eton dominated parliament at Westminster will crush any notion of Welsh identity, economic needs, and ambition.
Don't go along with Sun reading English bigots - stand up for Wales!
Sat May 28, 2016 1:12 pm
Sat May 28, 2016 1:47 pm
Nuclearblue wrote:ninianboy wrote:From a Welsh perspective we have to vote to remain in the EU.
If we leave then an Eton dominated parliament at Westminster will crush any notion of Welsh identity, economic needs, and ambition.
Don't go along with Sun reading English bigots - stand up for Wales!
Why has Wales got to stay in the EU ? Ohh they give us money to build roads and swimming pools, but then again it's the United Kingdoms money anyway. It's like me giving you a hundred quid and then me being grateful that you give me £2.50 back.
Sat May 28, 2016 2:00 pm
Sat May 28, 2016 3:41 pm
Sat May 28, 2016 4:41 pm
Sneggyblubird wrote:castleblue wrote:Sneggyblubird wrote:castleblue wrote:Nuclearblue wrote:AfricanBluebird wrote:I am completely in favour of staying in the EU, however that is not to say I don't think it needs overhauling in certain areas.
In terms of leaving I just don't think we understand the ramifications of it - there has been so little 'facts' based research on short, medium and long term ramifications. In the absence of this research people are very 'emotionally' motivated about leaving rather than making a considered decision.
Having a referendum at this stage is nonsense and there should have been much more consultation and research.
Now that is the problem Chief you can't overhaul something that isn't a democracy and is run like a communist style dictatorship. Cameron tried to overhaul it didn't he ? What happened there ? Yeah they took the piss out of him and he came away with jack shit and believe me he had leverage.
What I don't understand is that most don't realise it isn't democratic and you can't change or even attempt to change the EU laws.
In principle the EU is a good idea but it's ruined by by power hungry Marxist style dictators running the show.
In the world more country's ain't in the EU and do just fine.
I agree with most of that Nukes, Marxist dictators would probably be MORE democratic than this lot, and that for me is the biggest reason for voting leave, the ABSOLUTE undemocratic nature of the political system of the EU. I voted in the last referendum after the Harold Wilson government attempted to renegotiate the terms of membership. Since the Margaret Thatcher, Major, Blair, Brown and now Cameron have tried to either renegotiate or get agreement on the overhaul of the non democratic political system of the EU. Still our politicians say "Well it isn't perfect but we are better off inside trying to change the EU". BOLLOCKS it will NEVER change whilst the main "Council Of The EU" , the body that negotiates and implements EU Law is made up of non elected political appointments. In my opinion not since the "Doges of Venice" has there been such an undemocratic system of government but one after another our political leaders have shown a complete lack of desire to deal with this. It's UNBELIEVEABLE.
There are many examples of where the law created by this unelected "Council Of The EU" have had a negative effect on the UK and, in my opinion, the biggest relates to the "Free Movement Of Labour". This gives ABSOLUTE freedom for the migration of people across the EU and we now know that as a result the population of the UK has increased by over 2m in the last 5 years.
Unfortunately the LEAVE campaign continually talk about IMMIGRATION in relation to this issue, but immigration means the movement of people across International borders, a process where the UK still has complete control, whist migration means the movement of people within the borders of a single state, a process over which the UK has ABSOLUTELY NO CONTROL thanks to EU law so when people like Nigel Farage say we have lost of our borders he is only saying the truth. For that he is dubbed a racist. Unbelieveable.
Blair had the power to VETO this but he didn't and Cameron talks about us being outside the "Schengen" zone and claims as a result we still control our borders, A LIE, but still people are not waking up to the problems that are ahead of us if we do not get control of our borders back.
Almost ALL areas of our society are being put under pressure because of the level of uncontrolled migration into this country, housing, education, health, transport and employment are suffering and the only way to correct this is to get back control of our borders. To do this we need to exit the EU and as soon as possible.
I am not a racist and I honestly believe that controlled immigration has in the past, is today and will be in the future a massive positive for the UK and absolutely must continue. What has to STOP is the uncontrolled mass migration of people across the EU.
Vote leave and lets get back to the great democratic political system we enjoyed prior to joining this nutcase undemocratic EU we were mad enough to join over 40 years ago.
I wonder if either you or nuclear blue could actually tell us how the EU works without having to rescherch it first.Last time I looked we had our own unelected body which has been responsible for many changes to government proposed law and when all things are considered haven't done a bad job.
Having the House of Lords review legislation is one of the things that makes our political system great although I accept your point that nowadays there are so many political appoints that it can look like an institution created by vested interest.But the main LAW making body of this country remains the House of Commons and that is a directly elected democratic body.
Can you seriously claim that the Council of the EU is the same as the House Of Lords.
If your point is an un-elected body able to effect the making of laws then yes.My other main point you seemed to have dodged,that is,do you know the way the EU works and could you explain it in detail or are you dependent on that great closet bigot of our time,Boris Johnstone and his cronies.
Sat May 28, 2016 5:24 pm
Sat May 28, 2016 5:47 pm
Steve Zodiak wrote:Reports say that the younger generation tend to be more in favour of remaining in the EU, while the older generation favour an exit. Is that because the older generation can remember when we were'nt run by Brussels, while the younger generation have never known anything different.
Sat May 28, 2016 6:50 pm
Nuclearblue wrote:Jupiter wrote:I have seen no fact based information that supports leaving, so if you have some I would be glad to see it Sven.
The EU is 100% un democratic and is a dictatorship at Brussels who wasn't elected or can't be sacked. Tell me that is not true Chief.
Sat May 28, 2016 7:01 pm
Sat May 28, 2016 7:04 pm
Steve Zodiak wrote:No-on has really been able to tell me why Cameron has offered us the chance to get out if it's the disaster he is making it out to be. If everything is going to be as bad as he is making out, why on earth did he agree to the referendum in the first place.
Sat May 28, 2016 7:09 pm
Cool Hand Luke wrote:Wales independence and stay in,Europe!!
Sat May 28, 2016 7:11 pm
JJBluebird98 wrote:Steve Zodiak wrote:No-on has really been able to tell me why Cameron has offered us the chance to get out if it's the disaster he is making it out to be. If everything is going to be as bad as he is making out, why on earth did he agree to the referendum in the first place.
If you study the ins and the outs of the Conservative party then you would begin to understand why. First of all Cameron is gambler in fact he was once described as someone who was not drove by traditional conservative ideology but drove by winning elections, and he drove the Conservative party to the brink when he made his coalition offer to the Liberal Democrats live on TV which angered many of his conservative peers as the Liberal Democrats were 'Pro-European' compared to the old Eurosceptic of the conservative party. Further more, he risked the entire future of the Conservative party when they had the voting reform referendum of 2011 where if he lost that referendum that he backed a number of conservatives would of lost their seats and the likelihood of them ever gaining power again was pretty minute but he had won and the conservatives went on to get a majority in 2015 (his gamble paid off). The reason why he has agreed to have this referendum is to avoid a backbench revolt in the Conservative party but make no mistake he is Pro-EU
Sat May 28, 2016 7:17 pm
angelis1949 wrote:Bluebird since 1948 wrote:Owain wrote:Bluebird since 1948 wrote:Blue Gog in spreading lies and half truths shocker.
Notice in that little map he shared it says until 2020? Well guess what happens in 2019. The EU are negotiating the next round of funding and sadly for Wales we are likely to be not receive that amount again. We were lucky too last time, with every poorer regions joining the Union we are going to get bumped up.
I understand why people want to remain for the funding aspect and agree that Westminster are unlikely to invest that much into South Wales. However this funding is going to stop in a few years and we will be saddled with all the negatives of the EU without much of the positives for that I am voting to LEAVE.
Talking of spreading lies and half truths...
It will stop, they are reviewing it in 2019 and we were very close to losing top funding status back when it was last reviewed. At the moment we are getting a lot of money, that point I will concede. However this money will dry up and with all the shit holes joining the EU we will be budged up a bit.
Too much talk about immigration in this thread and others regarding the EU. If you are genuinely out, stop talking about immigration because it's turning many potential out voters off. There's plenty of arguments to leave the EU.
What Utter nonsense it is to suggest that talking about immigration it turning people off voting for Brexit,I would suggest the opposite is true,people who want less immigration will definetly vote leave
Sat May 28, 2016 7:32 pm
Sat May 28, 2016 7:42 pm
JJBluebird98 wrote:It makes me laugh when I hear Brexiteers talk about the economic reasons for leaving the EU. They do realise that the money we give to the EU works out at 27p per person in the UK. Are Brexiteers so desperate to get their 27p back?
Sat May 28, 2016 7:46 pm
JJBluebird98 wrote:angelis1949 wrote:Bluebird since 1948 wrote:Owain wrote:Bluebird since 1948 wrote:Blue Gog in spreading lies and half truths shocker.
Notice in that little map he shared it says until 2020? Well guess what happens in 2019. The EU are negotiating the next round of funding and sadly for Wales we are likely to be not receive that amount again. We were lucky too last time, with every poorer regions joining the Union we are going to get bumped up.
I understand why people want to remain for the funding aspect and agree that Westminster are unlikely to invest that much into South Wales. However this funding is going to stop in a few years and we will be saddled with all the negatives of the EU without much of the positives for that I am voting to LEAVE.
Talking of spreading lies and half truths...
It will stop, they are reviewing it in 2019 and we were very close to losing top funding status back when it was last reviewed. At the moment we are getting a lot of money, that point I will concede. However this money will dry up and with all the shit holes joining the EU we will be budged up a bit.
Too much talk about immigration in this thread and others regarding the EU. If you are genuinely out, stop talking about immigration because it's turning many potential out voters off. There's plenty of arguments to leave the EU.
What Utter nonsense it is to suggest that talking about immigration it turning people off voting for Brexit,I would suggest the opposite is true,people who want less immigration will definetly vote leave
How would we control immigration if we end up leaving the EU? Republic of Ireland is a EU country and has a open boarder with Northern Ireland which would be a non EU country. The Only way to control immigration and to tie up all loop holes would be to close the boarder between Northern and Republic of Ireland which would take years and years of negotiations which a new peace deal would have to be negotiated. and second introduce visa's which would make travel expensive. But I would always make the case that immigration is good for the UK
Sat May 28, 2016 8:13 pm
Sat May 28, 2016 9:44 pm
wez1927 wrote:JJBluebird98 wrote:It makes me laugh when I hear Brexiteers talk about the economic reasons for leaving the EU. They do realise that the money we give to the EU works out at 27p per person in the UK. Are Brexiteers so desperate to get their 27p back?
It's not 27p it's 288 pounds per head per year
Sat May 28, 2016 9:45 pm
Sat May 28, 2016 9:48 pm
pembroke allan wrote:JJBluebird98 wrote:angelis1949 wrote:Bluebird since 1948 wrote:Owain wrote:Bluebird since 1948 wrote:Blue Gog in spreading lies and half truths shocker.
Notice in that little map he shared it says until 2020? Well guess what happens in 2019. The EU are negotiating the next round of funding and sadly for Wales we are likely to be not receive that amount again. We were lucky too last time, with every poorer regions joining the Union we are going to get bumped up.
I understand why people want to remain for the funding aspect and agree that Westminster are unlikely to invest that much into South Wales. However this funding is going to stop in a few years and we will be saddled with all the negatives of the EU without much of the positives for that I am voting to LEAVE.
Talking of spreading lies and half truths...
It will stop, they are reviewing it in 2019 and we were very close to losing top funding status back when it was last reviewed. At the moment we are getting a lot of money, that point I will concede. However this money will dry up and with all the shit holes joining the EU we will be budged up a bit.
Too much talk about immigration in this thread and others regarding the EU. If you are genuinely out, stop talking about immigration because it's turning many potential out voters off. There's plenty of arguments to leave the EU.
What Utter nonsense it is to suggest that talking about immigration it turning people off voting for Brexit,I would suggest the opposite is true,people who want less immigration will definetly vote leave
How would we control immigration if we end up leaving the EU? Republic of Ireland is a EU country and has a open boarder with Northern Ireland which would be a non EU country. The Only way to control immigration and to tie up all loop holes would be to close the boarder between Northern and Republic of Ireland which would take years and years of negotiations which a new peace deal would have to be negotiated. and second introduce visa's which would make travel expensive. But I would always make the case that immigration is good for the UK
You saw the report on the news then, so must be true?
Sat May 28, 2016 10:40 pm
JJBluebird98 wrote:pembroke allan wrote:JJBluebird98 wrote:angelis1949 wrote:Bluebird since 1948 wrote:Owain wrote:Bluebird since 1948 wrote:Blue Gog in spreading lies and half truths shocker.
Notice in that little map he shared it says until 2020? Well guess what happens in 2019. The EU are negotiating the next round of funding and sadly for Wales we are likely to be not receive that amount again. We were lucky too last time, with every poorer regions joining the Union we are going to get bumped up.
I understand why people want to remain for the funding aspect and agree that Westminster are unlikely to invest that much into South Wales. However this funding is going to stop in a few years and we will be saddled with all the negatives of the EU without much of the positives for that I am voting to LEAVE.
Talking of spreading lies and half truths...
It will stop, they are reviewing it in 2019 and we were very close to losing top funding status back when it was last reviewed. At the moment we are getting a lot of money, that point I will concede. However this money will dry up and with all the shit holes joining the EU we will be budged up a bit.
Too much talk about immigration in this thread and others regarding the EU. If you are genuinely out, stop talking about immigration because it's turning many potential out voters off. There's plenty of arguments to leave the EU.
What Utter nonsense it is to suggest that talking about immigration it turning people off voting for Brexit,I would suggest the opposite is true,people who want less immigration will definetly vote leave
How would we control immigration if we end up leaving the EU? Republic of Ireland is a EU country and has a open boarder with Northern Ireland which would be a non EU country. The Only way to control immigration and to tie up all loop holes would be to close the boarder between Northern and Republic of Ireland which would take years and years of negotiations which a new peace deal would have to be negotiated. and second introduce visa's which would make travel expensive. But I would always make the case that immigration is good for the UK
You saw the report on the news then, so must be true?
No I didn't see the news report was it on BBC, Sky News or ITV? its just plain logistics for those who are aware of Northern Ireland and Republic of Ireland relations and the importance of the 'open' boarder that was negotiated as part of a peace deal.
Sat May 28, 2016 10:44 pm