Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO SIGN?

Fri Jan 18, 2013 9:56 pm

It seems every time we go for a good player it stalls and things hold up and they are hmming and arrrin about moving to cardiff city.
they either go else where or fall through at the final minute, where as other championship clubs tend to smoothly get the job done and i Remember we never use to have this big saga going back about 4 , 5 6 seasons.

Is their something about this club that players dont like, is it career concerns, or the owners or our financial position.
could it be the agents have an issue with cardiff city and always try to get there players to opt for somewhere else if possible?

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Fri Jan 18, 2013 10:19 pm

perhaps geography has something to do with it?

in regards the Campbell transfer, all accounts seem to suggest its not the player thats the problem.

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Fri Jan 18, 2013 10:26 pm

Maybe they've heard Cardiff ain't got a Woodies Emporium anymore and are gutted.

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Fri Jan 18, 2013 10:32 pm

It's just your paranoia and ignorance as to what actually happens in the world of player deals, agents, and managers vying for the best deal.

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Fri Jan 18, 2013 10:38 pm

I don't think we struggle to attract decent players. Not in recent seasons anyway. Yeah, we might miss out on 1 or 2 targets, but even man united miss out on a few targets now an then

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Fri Jan 18, 2013 10:41 pm

Bluetwin wrote:It's just your paranoia and ignorance as to what actually happens in the world of player deals, agents, and managers vying for the best deal.


:lol:

its not rocket science to suss out we've missed out on some players in recent seasons, it seems to be a commen incident, even alan shearer came down and had a change of heart after his meeting.

whatever you think I can assure you most clubs move swiftly and dont mess about.
look at chelsea and leicester two prime examples

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 9:16 am

sloper_road_legend wrote:It seems every time we go for a good player it stalls and things hold up and they are hmming and arrrin about moving to cardiff city.
they either go else where or fall through at the final minute, where as other championship clubs tend to smoothly get the job done and i Remember we never use to have this big saga going back about 4 , 5 6 seasons.

Is their something about this club that players dont like, is it career concerns, or the owners or our financial position.
could it be the agents have an issue with cardiff city and always try to get there players to opt for somewhere else if possible?

Did u use message board 4,5 6 years ago??????

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 11:25 am

Malky is abit slow in the windows too, that could be a part of it because if a club offers more money in the meantime. The player would be tempted away. Also Some players might be settled over the bridge.

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 11:57 am

sloper_road_legend wrote:It seems every time we go for a good player it stalls and things hold up and they are hmming and arrrin about moving to cardiff city.
they either go else where or fall through at the final minute, where as other championship clubs tend to smoothly get the job done and i Remember we never use to have this big saga going back about 4 , 5 6 seasons.

Is their something about this club that players dont like, is it career concerns, or the owners or our financial position.
could it be the agents have an issue with cardiff city and always try to get there players to opt for somewhere else if possible?


Because we don't have any decent players do we? :roll:

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 12:00 pm

I thought it may have been geography but we've lost out on a few players to Blackpool in the past.

Who the f**k would want to live up here?

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 12:05 pm

If they read this forum they'll never want to sign. One or two bad games and they're made the scapegoat. Imagine if Taylor, Cowie or Rudy read this board

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 12:32 pm

sloper_road_legend wrote:
Bluetwin wrote:It's just your paranoia and ignorance as to what actually happens in the world of player deals, agents, and managers vying for the best deal.


:lol:

its not rocket science to suss out we've missed out on some players in recent seasons, it seems to be a commen incident, even alan shearer came down and had a change of heart after his meeting.

whatever you think I can assure you most clubs move swiftly and dont mess about.
look at chelsea and leicester two prime examples



apart from those two clubs how many of the other league clubs have done any business. all the main deals will be done in the last 48 hours.
remember the last time we bought a striker in the first week of the window we ended up with jon parkin. apart from greggs who else in cardiff benefitted from that panic buy.
clubs will not let their top players go until they have a replacement. If sunderland sign danny graham i think you will find that the frazier deal will be concluded quite quickly

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 1:22 pm

Much of it is down to players and agents who hold out as long as they can hoping for as much cash as they can get.

I don't doubt sometimes it is also down to the club, therefor I would suggest everybody is at fault in different cases!

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 2:16 pm

The only reason you think that other teams transfers go through smoother than ours is because as a cardiff fan your aware of the build up to a signing other clubs half the time you won't realise theyre signing somone until they actually do.You have to be nieve if you think its different here to anywhere else.We have done excellent business in the last transfer window and the first summer malky was here! Transfer don't just happen overnight they take time your talking about moving peoples lives,family,possesions etc

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 2:21 pm

You can't blame players and clubs, everyone is waiting for the best deal they can and seeing all the options available.

Players will want to earn as much as possible and at the higher level they can.

No different to clubs, like MM will be looking at a lot of players in a lot of positions and will try and get the best deal.

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 2:44 pm

With the amount of crap posted on this board I'm amazed we are not all choking
on shit.

Bellamy, Gunnarsson, Maynard, Helgusson, Turner, Taylor, Noone, Kim Bo, Connelly
Smith, Mutch...

Thats a full team there that where he hasnt fucked the signings up!!!

Because he doesnt announce who he is after 6 weeks in advance some of you
clueless numpties think he's making a mess of things.

Its like pacifying children on here

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 2:46 pm

sloper_road_legend wrote:
Bluetwin wrote:It's just your paranoia and ignorance as to what actually happens in the world of player deals, agents, and managers vying for the best deal.


:lol:

its not rocket science to suss out we've missed out on some players in recent seasons, it seems to be a commen incident, even alan shearer came down and had a change of heart after his meeting.

whatever you think I can assure you most clubs move swiftly and dont mess about.
look at chelsea and leicester two prime examples


:lol: :lol: Are you suggesting Shearer was offered the job?? :? :?

Bollocks, as soon as he knew he wasn't likely to get it he called a press conference to
save face.

Re: WHY IS IT ALWAYS SO HARD TO CONVINCE DECENT PLAYERS TO S

Sat Jan 19, 2013 2:47 pm

taffyapple wrote:With the amount of crap posted on this board I'm amazed we are not all choking
on shit.

Bellamy, Gunnarsson, Maynard, Helgusson, Turner, Taylor, Noone, Kim Bo, Connelly
Smith, Mutch...

Thats a full team there that where he hasnt fucked the signings up!!!

Because he doesnt announce who he is after 6 weeks in advance some of you
clueless numpties think he's making a mess of things.

Its like pacifying children on here



Very true.