best City player of last 10 years ?

big debate in the pub tonight.

The plastics won't have it but for me it was Gabbidon. Before his injury he was really top class.

BTW I reckon bothroyd on his day could be good enough for most (except top 4/6) Prem sides.

To many beers ?

Koumas?

Koumas?

1 season and not technically ours. Good shout like, but overall doesnt beat gabbi for me.

dwyer for loyalty
buchanon for scoring that goal against the unwashed
and my fav ernie

dwyer for loyalty
buchanon for scoring that goal against the unwashed
and my fav ernie

sori just reread thread ladst ten years i go for ernie

Earnshaw or Mr. Joseph Ledley

Neil Alexander

Jason Perry and Phil Dwyer or they are more than 10 years ago. BUT THEY WERE SOLID and LOYAL BEYOND.

But Robert Earnshaw for me I LOVED HIS GOALS(and he was consistant) and ESPECIALLY HIS CELEBRATIONS, He knew how to get the crowd going

andy legg

Draw for me, between Earnie , Kav and Leggie. Hard to seperate, all gave 100% and loved the club.

Earnie, Gabby and Gary O'Neil (does he count?)

kav

earnshaw, kavanagh, roger j, super kev and gabbidon have all been class players for us

bothroyd and burke are well on their ways to joining them

Kevin McNaughton by a country mile!

Kavanagh

Peter Thorne,Shame he was so injury prone.

Earnie, Kav, Roger or Rambo

I know he was on loan but for me it's Gary O'Neil

last 10 years hay

for me EARNIE and the great times we had getting promotions, it was just like party mode everytime he scored

also second behind him was andy legg legg legg

Got to agree with Gary Oneil. Absolute quality when he played for us.

My favourite over the years tho has to be Andy Legg. Confident that every time he touched the ball he wouldnt lose it and loved the long throw

Earnie, Kav and Gabbidon! Awesome players who have had the privelage of playin at our club!

Earnie, Kav and Gabbidon! Awesome players who have had the privelage of playin at our club!

Changed my mind now .


JOE LEDLEY !!!!!!!!!!!!

EARNSHAW - awesome goalscoring record.

Earnie

Super Joe Ledley!!

Last 10yrs - Has to be Earnie!!!

No-one has mentioned James Collins

No-one has mentioned James Collins

I don't think he was the greatest City player of the last 10 years though. Only really blossomed since he left us. Great player though

gary o neil was great for us while he was here but he played 8 games! surely that cannot really qualify him.

the most gifted footballer i have ever seen play wore the shirt of Cardiff City. Aaron Ramsey was head and shoulders above everyone else just on his reading of the game and his vision.

but lets face it, the noughties haven't been too bad for us, we've had

GK
Alexander/Marshall

Defence
Gabbidon, Collins, Loovens, Johnson, McNaughton

Midfield
Kavanagh, Ledley, Ramsey, Koumas, O'Neil

Forwards
Earnshaw, Thorne

imagine them all playing together