Forever Blue wrote:Oops on FB
I have numerous fans laughing at me for even suggesting it.
Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Oops on FB
I have numerous fans laughing at me for even suggesting it.
I wouldn't laugh at you for suggesting it Annis, but is it possible? No, not in my opinion as Tomlin won't stay fit enough for a start and Wilson is a far superior player in my opinion
Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Oops on FB
I have numerous fans laughing at me for even suggesting it.
I wouldn't laugh at you for suggesting it Annis, but is it possible? No, not in my opinion as Tomlin won't stay fit enough for a start and Wilson is a far superior player in my opinion
I agree Neil,
It’s not a laughing idea, but as you say Tomlin keeping fit for a whole season or injury free is not likely to happen. Tomlin has never done it for his previous clubs and is always apologising a year later or saying you will see the new Tomlin ??
Wilson is as you say another level to Tomlin.
Problem is Tomlin has another year here ( madness ) and no other club will take his contract on.
Mick will have a tight budget and we will need to replace Harry Wilson??
Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Oops on FB
I have numerous fans laughing at me for even suggesting it.
I wouldn't laugh at you for suggesting it Annis, but is it possible? No, not in my opinion as Tomlin won't stay fit enough for a start and Wilson is a far superior player in my opinion
I agree Neil,
It’s not a laughing idea, but as you say Tomlin keeping fit for a whole season or injury free is not likely to happen. Tomlin has never done it for his previous clubs and is always apologising a year later or saying you will see the new Tomlin ??
Wilson is as you say another level to Tomlin.
Problem is Tomlin has another year here ( madness ) and no other club will take his contract on.
Mick will have a tight budget and we will need to replace Harry Wilson??
At the moment Annis it seems like it is a toss up between Tomlin or Jonniesta... Not ideal! I would like to see one of the youngsters given a go. Is it Calwill's natural position? I fear for us next season as we are potentially likely to see more quality going out than coming in..
Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Oops on FB
I have numerous fans laughing at me for even suggesting it.
I wouldn't laugh at you for suggesting it Annis, but is it possible? No, not in my opinion as Tomlin won't stay fit enough for a start and Wilson is a far superior player in my opinion
I agree Neil,
It’s not a laughing idea, but as you say Tomlin keeping fit for a whole season or injury free is not likely to happen. Tomlin has never done it for his previous clubs and is always apologising a year later or saying you will see the new Tomlin ??
Wilson is as you say another level to Tomlin.
Problem is Tomlin has another year here ( madness ) and no other club will take his contract on.
Mick will have a tight budget and we will need to replace Harry Wilson??
At the moment Annis it seems like it is a toss up between Tomlin or Jonniesta... Not ideal! I would like to see one of the youngsters given a go. Is it Calwill's natural position? I fear for us next season as we are potentially likely to see more quality going out than coming in..
Neil,
I don’t think we have as good here as Wilson and maybe we can get another good loan.
But l like you fear that to much quality will leave and we will be relying to much on youngsters who are by No way proven yet.
Regarding our squad:
For me Bagan is the best so far.
Brown for me League 1
Tom Sang could be a fairly good squad player.
Mark Harris in and out.
Need to see way more of the rest playing now.
Forever Blue wrote:Reply Twitter:
skidemin wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Oops on FB
I have numerous fans laughing at me for even suggesting it.
I wouldn't laugh at you for suggesting it Annis, but is it possible? No, not in my opinion as Tomlin won't stay fit enough for a start and Wilson is a far superior player in my opinion
I agree Neil,
It’s not a laughing idea, but as you say Tomlin keeping fit for a whole season or injury free is not likely to happen. Tomlin has never done it for his previous clubs and is always apologising a year later or saying you will see the new Tomlin ??
Wilson is as you say another level to Tomlin.
Problem is Tomlin has another year here ( madness ) and no other club will take his contract on.
Mick will have a tight budget and we will need to replace Harry Wilson??
At the moment Annis it seems like it is a toss up between Tomlin or Jonniesta... Not ideal! I would like to see one of the youngsters given a go. Is it Calwill's natural position? I fear for us next season as we are potentially likely to see more quality going out than coming in..
Neil,
I don’t think we have as good here as Wilson and maybe we can get another good loan.
But l like you fear that to much quality will leave and we will be relying to much on youngsters who are by No way proven yet.
Regarding our squad:
For me Bagan is the best so far.
Brown for me League 1
Tom Sang could be a fairly good squad player.
Mark Harris in and out.
Need to see way more of the rest playing now.
agree until the final line....we are relying too much on youngsters... and although ok not great { generally agree with your views on them individually } ... results 100% have suffered since our 1st team players started getting injured and we have been forced into using them....... so what makes you think flooding our team with more of these kids { who are even further down the pecking order } is going to achieve anything... our under 23s are not even a good under 23 side let alone stand out.....
rumpo kid wrote:McArthy should be the judge of a players suitability for the first team squad.. if a Chairman is telling the Manager what to do, he aint any Manager..
If fans dont bother next year fair enough. There's not even modest ambition at the club..Quid pro quo n'all that..
Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Oops on FB
I have numerous fans laughing at me for even suggesting it.
I wouldn't laugh at you for suggesting it Annis, but is it possible? No, not in my opinion as Tomlin won't stay fit enough for a start and Wilson is a far superior player in my opinion
I agree Neil,
It’s not a laughing idea, but as you say Tomlin keeping fit for a whole season or injury free is not likely to happen. Tomlin has never done it for his previous clubs and is always apologising a year later or saying you will see the new Tomlin ??
Wilson is as you say another level to Tomlin.
Problem is Tomlin has another year here ( madness ) and no other club will take his contract on.
Mick will have a tight budget and we will need to replace Harry Wilson??
At the moment Annis it seems like it is a toss up between Tomlin or Jonniesta... Not ideal! I would like to see one of the youngsters given a go. Is it Calwill's natural position? I fear for us next season as we are potentially likely to see more quality going out than coming in..
Neil,
I don’t think we have as good here as Wilson and maybe we can get another good loan.
But l like you fear that to much quality will leave and we will be relying to much on youngsters who are by No way proven yet.
Regarding our squad:
For me Bagan is the best so far.
Brown for me League 1
Tom Sang could be a fairly good squad player.
Mark Harris in and out.
Need to see way more of the rest playing now.
Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Bluebird For Life wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Oops on FB
I have numerous fans laughing at me for even suggesting it.
I wouldn't laugh at you for suggesting it Annis, but is it possible? No, not in my opinion as Tomlin won't stay fit enough for a start and Wilson is a far superior player in my opinion
I agree Neil,
It’s not a laughing idea, but as you say Tomlin keeping fit for a whole season or injury free is not likely to happen. Tomlin has never done it for his previous clubs and is always apologising a year later or saying you will see the new Tomlin ??
Wilson is as you say another level to Tomlin.
Problem is Tomlin has another year here ( madness ) and no other club will take his contract on.
Mick will have a tight budget and we will need to replace Harry Wilson??
At the moment Annis it seems like it is a toss up between Tomlin or Jonniesta... Not ideal! I would like to see one of the youngsters given a go. Is it Calwill's natural position? I fear for us next season as we are potentially likely to see more quality going out than coming in..
Neil,
I don’t think we have as good here as Wilson and maybe we can get another good loan.
But l like you fear that to much quality will leave and we will be relying to much on youngsters who are by No way proven yet.
Regarding our squad:
For me Bagan is the best so far.
Brown for me League 1
Tom Sang could be a fairly good squad player.
Mark Harris in and out.
Need to see way more of the rest playing now.
Yes Bagan looks a very good prospect and Sang has done better than most thought he would given he couldn;t get a game for Cheltenham. Brown for me needs to work on his passing and lacks pace but has done OK. Harris doesn't seem to have a role in the way we play and Mick doesn't seem to fancy Watters so we haven't seen enough of him. I think a lot will depend on who we keep for next season, but I would like to see some of these youngsters get a run out now that we are out of the play off mix. We are safe so it makes sense to me for Mick to see what they can do in the time left.
theclaw wrote:If Tomlin could get himself in the shape and form of the end of last season than yes he could,unfortunately as a player who carries a bit of weight and been out for a while it’s going to be extremely unlikely.
By the way I’d love to see the stats (games,goals assists,MOTM)for Tomlin last season and Wilson this season.
theclaw wrote:If Tomlin could get himself in the shape and form of the end of last season than yes he could,unfortunately as a player who carries a bit of weight and been out for a while it’s going to be extremely unlikely.
By the way I’d love to see the stats (games,goals assists,MOTM)for Tomlin last season and Wilson this season.
EastShoreBlue wrote:theclaw wrote:If Tomlin could get himself in the shape and form of the end of last season than yes he could,unfortunately as a player who carries a bit of weight and been out for a while it’s going to be extremely unlikely.
By the way I’d love to see the stats (games,goals assists,MOTM)for Tomlin last season and Wilson this season.
Tomlin:
Games - 35 / Minutes - 2,296
Goals - 9
Assists - 10
Wilson:
Games - 33 / Minutes - 2,510
Goals - 4
Assists - 12
And if you compare how their goal contributions changed a game. For example, 1 goal in a 3-0 win doesn't change the result but a goal in a game that ends 1-1 changes a loss into a draw
Tomlin:
7 Wins / 5 Draws
Wilson:
3 Wins / 3 Draws
EastShoreBlue wrote:theclaw wrote:If Tomlin could get himself in the shape and form of the end of last season than yes he could,unfortunately as a player who carries a bit of weight and been out for a while it’s going to be extremely unlikely.
By the way I’d love to see the stats (games,goals assists,MOTM)for Tomlin last season and Wilson this season.
Tomlin:
Games - 35 / Minutes - 2,296
Goals - 9
Assists - 10
Wilson:
Games - 33 / Minutes - 2,510
Goals - 4
Assists - 12
And if you compare how their goal contributions changed a game. For example, 1 goal in a 3-0 win doesn't change the result but a goal in a game that ends 1-1 changes a loss into a draw
Tomlin:
7 Wins / 5 Draws
Wilson:
3 Wins / 3 Draws
pembroke allan wrote:Playing wise yes but doesnt play enough games to be on an equal footing as harry.... certainly cannot base side around him
Users browsing this forum: Bakedalasker, Bambasbestbuddy22, Clickagy [Bot], Facebook [Bot], Google [Bot], Grapeshot [Bot], ias [Bot], Magpie [Bot], Proximic [Bot] and 208 guests