Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Cardiff City boss Mick McCarthy reveals 'heartbroken

Wed Apr 21, 2021 5:58 am

Cardiff City boss Mick McCarthy reveals 'heartbroken' Alex Smithies' dressing room reaction after Brentford clanger

The Bluebirds boss gave his assessment of the game following the 1-1 draw with Brentford on Tuesday evening


Alex Smithies of Cardiff City makes a mistake and fails to save from Tariqe Fosu of Brentford

Wednesday 20th April 2021


Mick McCarthy said Alex Smithies was 'broken hearted' in the Cardiff City dressing room after his error allowed Brentford to earn a 1-1 draw on Tuesday night.

The Bluebirds took the lead through a Kieffer Moore penalty but just six minutes later disaster struck when Smithies allowed a long-range effort from Tariqe Fosu to slip through his fingers and into the net.

It was a big gut blow for City, who had done tremendously well to keep this vaunted Bees frontline at bay for most of the evening, as they had to settle for a point in the end.

"I thought our first-half performance was excellent," McCarthy said. "We had a good bit of the ball and, created some chances, I didn't think we gave them too many chances.





MICK McCARTHY:


"They had one Alex made a great save from, he got in behind Perry (Ng) and Smudger made a great save from that.

"Second half, we've had our backs against the wall against a good side in Brentford. That's why they are where they are and why they've been there all season.

"Poor old Smudge, I feel for him, because he is sat in the dressing room and really broken hearted. But that's what happens, I suppose, it's a goalkeeper's life. He made a great save in the first half.

"We were having to defend, but I still thought we might nick it. Pleased with an overall good performance."

Smithies made some decent saves in the first half, most notably keeping Ivan Toney at bay when he was clean through, sticking a right mitt out to deny the forward from point-blank range.

And the manager acknowledged that without Smithies' first-half performance, Cardiff might not have been in the contest at all.

"You've got to treat them with a lot of love, care and attention," the manager said of how he deals with players who have made an error. "I've been there, you make a mistake.

"That save in the first half, if that had gone in we might have had a real onslaught, who knows what the score might have been.

"It's a mistake, we all make them, we'll be fine."


He added: "If you ask him he'd tell you he should have saved it - and he should have done.

"But that's the life of goalkeepers, defenders, I'm not going to criticise him.

"He's been brilliant, they both have (Smithies and Dillon Phillips), they've both had their tough times and you've just got to support them."
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: Cardiff City boss Mick McCarthy reveals 'heartbroken

Wed Apr 21, 2021 7:50 am

Clangers have become a part of his game unfortunately.Think Dillion will be back in now.

Re: Cardiff City boss Mick McCarthy reveals 'heartbroken

Wed Apr 21, 2021 7:57 am

2 mistakes in 3 games that probably cost us 4 points. At a time when only 1 experienced goalkeeper is likely to be with us next season, Phillips must now be in the pole position for that place.

My opinion, for what it’s worth, is that we should let Smithies go and use George Ratcliffe as back up.

Re: Cardiff City boss Mick McCarthy reveals 'heartbroken

Wed Apr 21, 2021 8:04 am

bluebird58 wrote:2 mistakes in 3 games that probably cost us 4 points. At a time when only 1 experienced goalkeeper is likely to be with us next season, Phillips must now be in the pole position for that place.

My opinion, for what it’s worth, is that we should let Smithies go and use George Ratcliffe as back up.


Not only the mistakes but I think he has had a poor season overall.. poor distribution and poor communication.

Dillion is unlucky to have lost his place. He was sadly made a scapegoat for the 5-0 loss when in reality none of the goals were his fault... it must be disheartening that players in that loss who performed so so poorly kept their places when he didn't.

I don't think many fans would disagree with your assertion that Dillion will be No. 1 next year with Ratcliffe as back up.

Re: Cardiff City boss Mick McCarthy reveals 'heartbroken

Wed Apr 21, 2021 12:40 pm

AfricanBluebird wrote:
bluebird58 wrote:2 mistakes in 3 games that probably cost us 4 points. At a time when only 1 experienced goalkeeper is likely to be with us next season, Phillips must now be in the pole position for that place.

My opinion, for what it’s worth, is that we should let Smithies go and use George Ratcliffe as back up.


Not only the mistakes but I think he has had a poor season overall.. poor distribution and poor communication.

Dillion is unlucky to have lost his place. He was sadly made a scapegoat for the 5-0 loss when in reality none of the goals were his fault... it must be disheartening that players in that loss who performed so so poorly kept their places when he didn't.

I don't think many fans would disagree with your assertion that Dillion will be No. 1 next year with Ratcliffe as back up.


Part of the reason for dropping Phillips was not just the 5-0 at Sheff Weds but the one he watched go in which gave Watford three points at CCS.

Smithies seems low on confidence at the moment - that's two howlers in recent games. the first Blackburn goal and last night's mistake. He also didn't exactly cover himself in glory with Blackburn's second goal either.