A VIEW FROM TWO FORMER CITY STARS

How do you solve a problem like Cardiff City?

Ex-Bluebirds Blake and Gabbidon and fans have their say


After back-to-back heavy defeats in the Championship, Cardiff City fans have expressed their unhappiness at manager Mick McCarthy with boos at the stadium and comments online.

Former Bluebirds Nathan Blake and Danny Gabbidon have also had their say as Cardiff lie 10th in the table with three wins, two draws and five league losses so far in 2021-22.

Blake believes issues beyond tactics, selection and playing standards that need to be considered.

Gabbidon points to a lack of "fight" among the players, who he says also neglected the game's basics in Tuesday's 4-0 home defeat by West Bromwich Albion that followed their 5-1 hammering at Blackburn Rovers.


Here is what ex-Cardiff City and Wales striker Nathan Blake told BBC Radio Wales:

"There's been a plethora of problems over the last two or three seasons and the decision-making at the top has been pretty woeful.

"I've said for many a year Cardiff have no philosophy, so when you're in a situation where you keep changing managers and the type of football that's been brought in, you're always going to set yourself up for a fall.

"I did think it was a bit harsh [booing by fans aimed at McCarthy] but they work every day, they follow the team all over the place and they're more than entitled to their opinion.

"If you look at last night, basically Cardiff played with eight defenders and two attackers, James Collins and Ryan Giles.

"You can't win games in the Championship with Giles and Collins.

"I heard people saying 'oh, five centre-backs'. Never mind five centre-backs, you've got eight defensive-minded players - you're never going to do it.

"So they've got major problems, for me.

"And it's not just on the pitch and I've said it for many a year, it's throughout the club."


With Cardiff hosting Reading on Saturday, Blake fears for what is in store for Cardiff's players and believes the club's owners and powerbrokers have issues to address:

"You don't want to play at home when your confidence is knocked the way it is for Cardiff at the moment.

"They've got themselves in a really serious situation, because there's little or no investment coming in from the top.

"Because they have no philosophy they've allowed manager after manager to bring in players that - listen, they are footballers - but they are not going to get you to the top of the Championship.

"You had teams like Barnsley up at the top last season; okay, they're struggling this season.

"But there's more and more teams playing football now and taking nothing away from the manager, he's had two promotions out of this division, but that was a long time ago.

"So you have to look at the type of players you're signing, but if you don't have the people who understand the game in charge, then if you're [owner] Vincent Tan it's going to continue to cost you money.

"I heard [BBC Wales football correspondent] Rob Phillips say to [ex-Bluebird on the Call Rob show] Jason Perry on the weekend, 'oh, you know he's putting £3m a month in'. He's having to do that because they're not in the Premier League.

"I feel sorry for the man [Tan], but at the end of the day the buck stops with him. You can't keep going around in this circle expecting there to be success.

"What do they say? 'Only a fool does the same thing and expects a different result'?"


As for McCarthy's future, Blake had this to say:

"He's the type of manager who will stay and will fight. I look at the team and think 'what's happened to all that pressing?'.

"After Mick came in last season, they some great results and got themselves in contention.

"What's happened to that pressing? There's none of that. Defensive shape is all over the place.

"There's no attacking players - the attacking players they had last season are gone.

"Yes, Mick is the type who will fight and fight to the bitter end, but I don't understand why he seems to have gone away from playing more football and a pressing game to now, where there's little or nothing of nothing.

"You're just reliant upon Giles to put the ball in for [Wales striker] Kieffer Moore - you have to play Kieffer Moore weekly. You have to let himself play himself into form.

"But do I think Mick will go? That's kind of been the process at the club, hasn't it? It's all on the manager so it's his fault.

"There's no responsibility, accountability taken within the board, within the transfer committee or within the ownership, so probably yes [he'll stay]."

You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

This is what former Bluebirds and Wales defender Danny Gabbidon had to say:

"There's no intensity, there's no desire and I don't know why that is. Are they not happy with the manager? I don't know.

"First and foremost as a player, you don't like every manager or how you play, but you go out there first and foremost and play for yourself and the fans and you still want to try and win games.

"But we can talk about the style of play and all that stuff - okay, we want to see better football.

"At times it was like a hot potato when West Brom pressed, Cardiff City were found wanting, they didn't really know what to do in possession, turned the ball over too often.

"But you can still do the basics of the game, you know, defend correctly, show some heart, play for your team-mates, throw yourself into tackles, block shots - all these things.

"It's the basics that Cardiff were doing quite well last season under Mick and that's why they were getting results.

"And they had someone up front in Kieffer Moore who was sticking the ball in the back of the net.

McCarthy pledges to do all he can to lift Bluebirds
"But I'm looking at this Cardiff City team now and they're not even doing the basics right and you've got no chance of winning any game if you're not going to work for your team-mate, if you're not going to be organised, if you're not going to try and put up a fight.

"I'm not seeing any fight from this Cardiff City team - that's what's alarming - and when you get to that stage as a manager you are under pressure.

"Mick'll know he's under pressure now. The last three or four performances have been nowhere near good enough and he will know that the buck stops with him now."

"There's a lot of issues going on with this Cardiff City team and it's all seemed to have come in the last four or five games really, because I thought the start of the season wasn't too bad.

"I wouldn't say they were playing brilliantly, but they got a few results at the start of the season, a good comeback against Nottingham Forest so you're thinking, 'okay the fight and the spirit, all those things are still there".

"He's [McCarthy] going to have to use all his experience now and find out what the problem is with these players otherwise he's going to be gone. It's as simple as that.

"But I still think these players can play a lot better."

Fan Barry Murphy from Pontypridd, a season-ticket holder for 22 years:

"For me the whole footballing philosophy needs to change. For the last eight-nine years we've been watching long, direct football.

"At least when [Neil] Warnock was in charge there was a little bit of spark and a little bit of flair.

"But since McCarthy's come in… there's no spark and no flair.

"It's all well and good giving these kids a chance - and I love seeing the academy boys come through.

"But they're being taught way in the academy and the Under-23s but they get a chance in the first team and they're playing long, direct, dinosaur football.

"It's no good for their progression and it's no fun for us to watch either.

"The whole club needs to change from top to bottom. The people appointing these managers are going for the safe, uninspiring choice which means the same direct football.

"Unless they change the philosophy of how they want to play football, the football will never change.

"The whole things needs to be ripped up and start again and if that means a season of consolidation then so be it - let's build for the future."


Fan Ben Price, View from the Ninian Podcast:

"It's horrible to watch and it's no fun and I can understand why people are saying that when they watch it on TV they feel empty. Leaving the stadium I felt similar to be honest.

"I think most City fans when McCarthy got the long-term contract a few months ago could see this coming a mile off.

"We all knew 'ok, he's going to do well, but this is only going to end one way' and to be honest I'm surprised it's happened so quickly. But we all knew it was coming.

"We knew what we were going to get with McCarthy and it's not like we're surprised by how his football's been.

"This solely lands with the board and their short-term visions and uninspiring picks.

"They've got to start thinking long term - it's been so short term every time and other than Warnock it's not really worked.

"[Neil] Harris they gave a go to then things didn't work out so they made the change and they went back to the safe, cheap option with no real foresight.

"What we're disappointed by as much as anything is the lack of long-term vision by the board."

I have to say each of those above make some excellent and valid points

It's certainly not all down to one individual and maybe it's the 'whole' that needs to take stock right now...?

I have to say each of those above make some excellent and valid points

It's certainly not all down to one individual and maybe it's the 'whole' that needs to take stock right now...?

Blake as an agenda with the hyarchy at city on several occasions he as gone public to say same things just blaming the board for everything wrong at club nothing about manager or players even when asked opinion on them..... tbh not impressed by either as pundits but guess it makes for debate to some.

I have to say each of those above make some excellent and valid points

It's certainly not all down to one individual and maybe it's the 'whole' that needs to take stock right now...?

Blake as an agenda with the hyarchy at city on several occasions he as gone public to say same things just blaming the board for everything wrong at club nothing about manager or players even when asked opinion on them..... tbh not impressed by either as pundits but guess it makes for debate to some.

To be fair Al, Blake has criticised the board for a lack of football knowledge in appointing managers, such as Trollope, Slade, Ole etc. He's also said that we have no overall philosophy as an as essential core and he's right.
As a result he said we need more football expertise at board level for long term strategy which i agree with.

Where we are right now has been ultimately been determined by the boards decions.

Tan has provided funding, still does and as a result we are financially stable. But he appointed and has mostly had the wrong advice on footballing matters from his appointed right hand men at Cardiff, Dalman and Choo who have no expertise and experience/track record in football. This is the bottleneck and has to change if they indeed still have ambitions for the club.

My concern is that by their silence and visible absence is now that they now don't and we are simply seen as a failed project to get off the books.

I read earlier that the new exec, Jalil Rasheed stated that his goal as CEO of the Berjaya Group is to rationalise their business portfolio. Is that what we are now seeing?

For quite sometime, I would have liked to have seen a truly compentant Director Of Football on the board to advise Dalman and Choo. Whilst it's not always the answer, I think it would have made a great difference over the last 10 years and we would be as a club in a far better place.

...meant to say that Blake has criticised the board for many years on the reasons above...

I have to say each of those above make some excellent and valid points

It's certainly not all down to one individual and maybe it's the 'whole' that needs to take stock right now...?

Blake as an agenda with the hyarchy at city on several occasions he as gone public to say same things just blaming the board for everything wrong at club nothing about manager or players even when asked opinion on them..... tbh not impressed by either as pundits but guess it makes for debate to some.

To be fair Al, Blake has criticised the board for a lack of football knowledge in appointing managers, such as Trollope, Slade, Ole etc. He's also said that we have no overall philosophy as an as essential core and he's right.
As a result he said we need more football expertise at board level for long term strategy which i agree with.

Where we are right now has been ultimately been determined by the boards decions.

Tan has provided funding, still does and as a result we are financially stable. But he appointed and has mostly had the wrong advice on footballing matters from his appointed right hand men at Cardiff, Dalman and Choo who have no expertise and experience/track record in football. This is the bottleneck and has to change if they indeed still have ambitions for the club.

My concern is that by their silence and visible absence is now that they now don't and we are simply seen as a failed project to get off the books.

I read earlier that the new exec, Jalil Rasheed stated that his goal as CEO of the Berjaya Group is to rationalise their business portfolio. Is that what we are now seeing?

For quite sometime, I would have liked to have seen a truly compentant Director Of Football on the board to advise Dalman and Choo. Whilst it's not always the answer, I think it would have made a great difference over the last 10 years and we would be as a club in a far better place.

Good response, Paul

Nathan can often be contradictory and selective but on this occasion makes some valued observations; as do all those quoted

We don't have to agree with it all but that alone doesn't make their opinions less valid

I have to say each of those above make some excellent and valid points

It's certainly not all down to one individual and maybe it's the 'whole' that needs to take stock right now...?

Blake as an agenda with the hyarchy at city on several occasions he as gone public to say same things just blaming the board for everything wrong at club nothing about manager or players even when asked opinion on them..... tbh not impressed by either as pundits but guess it makes for debate to some.

Your right they are average pundits and neither could manage a team and its complexities

Not sure if repeating something means you have an agenda or just that you believe something to be the case and events do nothing to change that view?

Tans continuing putting money in is all down to the decisions his own board have made. That's the reality and that's what Blake is saying. The board is weak, largely unchanged and the only football voice is our list of managers since Malkay. Ole, Trollope, Slade, Harris and now Mccarthy. The only exception, for sheer personality was Warnock, but his footballing style is what it is.

The players and manager have had a season and half with no direct contact with the fans. They have not been held to account - both good and bad by the fans.

I dont think either Mick or players have got re used to being in front of fans and having to ensure they are well prepared for a match.

Tues and the previous Saturday proved this. It's not only other teams that have sussed the players and manager out - it's the fans as well.

If there is no change on Saturday , no fight etc - then the Mick's dead in the water - and so are some of the players come the end of the season / christmas.

If they want to go back to empty stadiums again - then it will soon be happening as people just wont be bothered to pay money to watch a team that doesnt care.