Page 1 of 1

Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 5:15 pm
by Danny Says
Don’t think you can spilt them - they are all terrible and non-league standard.
Cannot believe we have a manager who played all 4 today either from the start which was bad enough but then from the bench.
Our manager is as bad as them :banghead: :banghead:

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 5:45 pm
by bluebirdoct1962
Danny Says wrote:Don’t think you can spilt them - they are all terrible and non-league standard.
Cannot believe we have a manager who played all 4 today either from the start which was bad enough but then from the bench.
Our manager is as bad as them :banghead: :banghead:

Personally I thought Brown was ok

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 5:53 pm
by theclaw
Collins for me

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 6:01 pm
by RV Casual
Calm down mate

We are having a tough time but they are not non league standard.

A change in manager and each player you have mentioned could be your hero in a few weeks.

Don't let your frustrations make you talk shit cos you can guarantee it will come back and bite you on the arse

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 6:07 pm
by boyo1927
All need go.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 6:33 pm
by mugsy
All poor - but Bacuna is the worst of the lot.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 8:45 pm
by troobloo3339
Bacuna collins voalks not sure whats happening with him
Then brown being played out of position needs to play centre back along side mcguiness with ng and bagan
As a back 4 they are the future

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 9:49 pm
by Danny Says
RV Casual wrote:Calm down mate

We are having a tough time but they are not non league standard.

A change in manager and each player you have mentioned could be your hero in a few weeks.

Don't let your frustrations make you talk shit cos you can guarantee it will come back and bite you on the arse

RV

They are all useless.
The only mitigation for Brown is he’s playing out of position - at best he’s a League 1 left sided CB.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 10:40 pm
by Bonner
personally think Brown , Collins ok

moore needs to vary his forward play a bit more.. far too predictable

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 02, 2021 10:46 pm
by ThomasC
mugsy wrote:All poor - but Bacuna is the worst of the lot.

He's got my vote today. Like playing with 10

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sun Oct 03, 2021 3:36 am
by BaltimoreBlues
I feel sorry for Brown having to play out of position, so it’s hard to be critical of him. I’m not sure what’s happening with Vaulks at the moment, but at least he try’s to show some passion for the club. The winner has to be Bacuna, his whole attitude and desire just stinks.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sun Oct 03, 2021 6:44 am
by CantonStandBob
Think this post is a bit harsh especially on Brown, I think he has been alright this week which sounds odd when we have conceded 5. Our problems lie further forward and my answer would be Bacuna based on form but he is constantly played out of position and MM is making it worse selecting him every game despite his confidence being shot. Vaulks and Collins are offering nothing but I wouldn't say it's lack of effort there just seems to be a cloud over the squad that needs lifting but posts like this and booing Bacuna in the stadium yesterday like some did doesn't help. None of them are going out there to play badly.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sun Oct 03, 2021 6:52 am
by bluebirdoct1962
CantonStandBob wrote:Think this post is a bit harsh especially on Brown, I think he has been alright this week which sounds odd when we have conceded 5. Our problems lie further forward and my answer would be Bacuna based on form but he is constantly played out of position and MM is making it worse selecting him every game despite his confidence being shot. Vaulks and Collins are offering nothing but I wouldn't say it's lack of effort there just seems to be a cloud over the squad that needs lifting but posts like this and booing Bacuna in the stadium yesterday like some did doesn't help. None of them are going out there to play badly.

I agree. I never have and never will boo a city player. Criticise but not boo.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sun Oct 03, 2021 7:04 am
by oohahhPaulMillar
Collins is a proven goalscorer but gets no service in this team

Vaux is an international player just completely out of form

Bacuna is average at best

Brown is decent but being played out of position

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Mon Oct 04, 2021 3:50 pm
by 1980s Bluebird
either of them hit the winner against the Jacks..... :ayatollah:

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Mon Oct 04, 2021 3:56 pm
by Lengee
Pack
:shock:
:bluebird:

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Mon Oct 04, 2021 4:42 pm
by darran1927
Bacuna, however he’s being played out of position. Collins I think just needs a goal I think he works hard every game

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Mon Oct 04, 2021 5:48 pm
by valleymodeller
oohahhPaulMillar wrote:Collins is a proven goalscorer but gets no service in this team

Vaux is an international player just completely out of form

Bacuna is average at best

Brown is decent but being played out of position


Pretty much what is said above. Bacuna is consistently poor, at best average. Brown is inexperienced and deserves a chance, and he's really centre back. Vaulks was very good mostly last season, and the tail end of the one before. Collins has a good track record but has done nothing as yet for City.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Mon Oct 04, 2021 5:58 pm
by Ian Gibson fanclub
Never mind Collins, Vaulks and Brown, Bacuna is right up there amongst our worse players ever

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Mon Oct 04, 2021 8:28 pm
by Bigmarkw
Brown by a long shot for me. He is non league.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Tue Oct 05, 2021 8:59 am
by Sven
Danny Says wrote:Don’t think you can spilt them - they are all terrible and non-league standard.
Cannot believe we have a manager who played all 4 today either from the start which was bad enough but then from the bench.
Our manager is as bad as them :banghead: :banghead:

None of them is 'bad' but may be out of their depth or just in the wrong formation

Bacuna is being played out of position and is being hung out to dry. A return to his natural position woukd see a big improvement. Round pegs in round holes springs to mind

Brown seemed okay overall on Saturday and put in some decent tackles/headers. He's not first choice but he's a decent squad member

Vaulks is so bad he's just had a recall to the Wales squad after seemingly being frozen out! He certainly has his moments, has a more than decent throw, although he does seem to get booked every game. Temperament or enthusiasm? Personally, I think the latter and he just seems to be another easy target for some

Collins appears to be out of his depth but his time at Luton suggests that is not the case. He also works hard, does some good work and maybe just needs a Championship goal to set him going. He was certainly prolific in pre-season

Time to get behind our players right now and show them we are there for them on the pitch rather than 'knock' them and their confidence. Now there's a novel idea...

I'm sure they do care and goals apart, Saturday was a massive improvement

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Thu Oct 07, 2021 12:48 pm
by Scoularite
by Sven » Tue Oct 05, 2021 8:59 am

Danny Says wrote:
Don’t think you can spilt them - they are all terrible and non-league standard.
Cannot believe we have a manager who played all 4 today either from the start which was bad enough but then from the bench.
Our manager is as bad as them :banghead: :banghead:

None of them is 'bad' but may be out of their depth or just in the wrong formation

Bacuna is being played out of position and is being hung out to dry. A return to his natural position woukd see a big improvement. Round pegs in round holes springs to mind

Brown seemed okay overall on Saturday and put in some decent tackles/headers. He's not first choice but he's a decent squad member

Vaulks is so bad he's just had a recall to the Wales squad after seemingly being frozen out! He certainly has his moments, has a more than decent throw, although he does seem to get booked every game. Temperament or enthusiasm? Personally, I think the latter and he just seems to be another easy target for some

Collins appears to be out of his depth but his time at Luton suggests that is not the case. He also works hard, does some good work and maybe just needs a Championship goal to set him going. He was certainly prolific in pre-season

Time to get behind our players right now and show them we are there for them on the pitch rather than 'knock' them and their confidence. Now there's a novel idea...

I'm sure they do care and goals apart, Saturday was a massive improvement


Good answer.

The problem is that we do not really have a squad that can play in a "balanced" team, and we have very little creativity. This obviously makes it very difficult for Collins (and even Kieffer Moore who was a bit of a star last season).
Bacuna is regularly being played out of position so it's impossible to judge, Vaulks has been very effective when part of a "balanced" midfield, and Ciaron Brown is a decent squad player.

The problem for me is the lack of creativity in the squad.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Fri Oct 08, 2021 12:19 am
by Sam ReaN
Collins & Bacuna
I unfortunately can see a situation with Collins in which he wont score for us and the last time that happened was when we had Gary Madine. Not Collins fault but he is just slow in pace and reaction hense the reason he cant score or get into that position to score a goal.

As for Bacuna well he is just gone off the boil this season along with many others but Bacuna miss sitters earlier this season so yeah.

Re: Who is worse - Bacuna Vaulks Brown or Collins?

PostPosted: Sun Oct 10, 2021 12:46 am
by Scoularite
by Sam ReaN » Fri Oct 08, 2021 12:19 am

Collins & Bacuna
I unfortunately can see a situation with Collins in which he wont score for us and the last time that happened was when we had Gary Madine. Not Collins fault but he is just slow in pace and reaction hense the reason he cant score or get into that position to score a goal.

As for Bacuna well he is just gone off the boil this season along with many others but Bacuna miss sitters earlier this season so yeah.


Bacuna is being played out of position while playing Collins up front alone with so little creativity and supporting players in the box makes him easier to mark and probably getting low on confidence. He did score 72 goals in 183 appearances for Luton which is not a bad return so he knows where the back of the net is.