Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was never a

Sun Aug 07, 2022 7:12 am

Ince Red Card - bullocks :

It was never a red card for Nelson ……..as Ince (the manager) asserts. At the point of contact for the correctly awarded penalty


(1) their goalkeeper was not the last man ….there was another who had recovered and was closer to goal .


(2) also correctly - albeit to a lesser degree- Ince (junior) was not in a goal scoring position and was forcibly running away from goal . Ince (manager) is a very well known whinger . Yes , we lost fair and square on the day ….. but it was not a red card .

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 7:59 am

100% agree. No red card

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 8:30 am

Agreed; but 100% penalty that shouln't have occurred :(

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 8:32 am

Sven wrote:Agreed; but 100% penalty that shouln't have occurred :(

Clear push on Kipre, Chris. Could see it even more clearly on the football league show

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 9:38 am

Sven wrote:Agreed; but 100% penalty that shouln't have occurred :(



Yes blatant penalty by Nelson, awful as no need.

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 9:39 am

Had commentary from reading tv and was ott in the extreme as was still whinging about it upto final whistle.... but as people say was not in scoring position unless he's a contortionist......
If anything you can easily say wouldn't have scored even without Nelson's intervention.

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 9:39 am

bluebirdoct1962 wrote:100% agree. No red card



I have looked time and time again Andrew, No red card but def a penalty.

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 9:40 am

pembroke allan wrote:Had commentary from reading tv and was ott in the extreme as was still whinging about it upto final whistle.... but as people say was not in scoring position unless he's a contortionist......
If anything you can easily say wouldn't have scored even without Nelson's intervention.



100% not a red card as to penalty without a doubt.

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 10:06 am

Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:Had commentary from reading tv and was ott in the extreme as was still whinging about it upto final whistle.... but as people say was not in scoring position unless he's a contortionist......
If anything you can easily say wouldn't have scored even without Nelson's intervention.



100% not a red card as to penalty without a doubt.


Annis, big difference at the back without NG, I am sorry but Nelson is not up to it. It was not just the penalty but he has no idea how to play out from the back.
I have been told that SM is going to bring in another centre half.
It does seem that SM only rates the two centre halves who started against Norwich. :thumbup: :ayatollah:

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 10:13 am

Igovernor wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:Had commentary from reading tv and was ott in the extreme as was still whinging about it upto final whistle.... but as people say was not in scoring position unless he's a contortionist......
If anything you can easily say wouldn't have scored even without Nelson's intervention.



100% not a red card as to penalty without a doubt.


Annis, big difference at the back without NG, I am sorry but Nelson is not up to it. It was not just the penalty but he has no idea how to play out from the back.
I have been told that SM is going to bring in another centre half.
It does seem that SM only rates the two centre halves who started against Norwich. :thumbup: :ayatollah:


Rog, the only worry I have with NG is a lack of aerial dominance but I’d still start him over Nelson and McGuiness. It’s a shame that Denham isn’t thought of as ready yet as I think he should be next in line rather than CM or MM. Glad another one is being pursued though.

Re: Ince Red Card - bullocks : It was neve

Sun Aug 07, 2022 10:36 am

Forever Blue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:Had commentary from reading tv and was ott in the extreme as was still whinging about it upto final whistle.... but as people say was not in scoring position unless he's a contortionist......
If anything you can easily say wouldn't have scored even without Nelson's intervention.



100% not a red card as to penalty without a doubt.



Oh definitely a pen but whole situation was poorly defended even aslop just rushed out and did nothing ... Nelson well just panicked unnecessarily but hopefully situation being addressed regarding defenders.