" Best and worst football pundits & presenters "

Just seen that Jake Humphrey is leaving BT Sport. Good riddance in my view, think he's an awful presenter.

Made me think.. what's your best and worst pundits and presenters on TV at the moment. Here's mine, five for each pundits on best and worst and a few on the best and worst presenters (as there aren't as many).


Best presenters: Mark Chapman, David Jones, Kelly Cates, David Prutton, Jeff Stelling

Worst presenters: Gary Lineker, Jake Humphrey


Best pundits: Gary Neville, Jamie Carragher, Alan Shearer, Roy Keane, Ally McCoist


Worst pundits: Earnie (sorry), Rio Ferdinand, Jermaine Jenas, Andy Hinchcliffe, Don Goodman


If it was radio as well, I'd include Kevin Ratcliffe in the worst.

Also like Alan Smith on Sky, but wanted to keep it down to five.

Worst: Jenas, keown, Michael Owen, Martin O'Neil(good manager) just bores me.

Best: micah Richards, carragher, Roy Keane, Gary Neville. Linkeker, shearer. Chapman. Michael dawson

Radio: adrian Durham, Sam matterface, Jamie ohara

Best saint and Greavsy

Worst Alex scott mark Lawrenson

Fittest Karen Carney and Jaime Rednapp

The funniest is Ian Wright, I met him in Doha and he is a mad a a box of frogs but Roy Keane was a bucket of shit

Steve Mcmanaman more commentator but he makes me want to switch off. Michael owne too...

Best pundit:Keane, Danny Murphy

Worst Pundit: Jenas

Worst radio commentator: Vicki Sparks, she has a really fake voice, it's awful yet the BBC put her on everything.

Fittest Karen Carney and Jaime Rednapp

You must like your women butch. Not judging.

probably not a common one, but i like Keith Andrews on sky


i dislike with an absolute passion Sam Matterface

The baffling thing about Jermaine Jenas is his confidence, he's terrible but someone at the Beeb must be bigging him up to the point Jenas himself thanks that he's top drawer.

probably not a common one, but i like Keith Andrews on sky


i dislike with an absolute passion Sam Matterface

Agree on both. Andrews is very good on the EFL, seems to have been on less this season though - think he was doing some work with the Ireland team.

Matterface is awful. Baffled me that ITV replaced Clive Tyldesley with him, because Tyldesley is a good commentator.

Bellamy is the best pundit by a mile, so honest and knowledgeable, I like Keane and Neville, Souness was alright at times too.

Dion Dublin has to be the worst commentator ever! Cannot stand listening to the man!

Worst pundits: Hartson and Sutton
Best pundits : Chapman and Souness
Worst presenter: Lineker
Best: Jason Mohamed