Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

" Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 7:39 pm

With just a few days to go until the start of the season, what would be your starting 11 for the Leeds game with our current squad?

Here's mine, gone with Alnwick in goal as Allsop picked up an injury.


Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O'Dowda

Wintle Adams

Bowler Ramsey Robinson

Grant

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 7:47 pm

worcester_ccfc wrote:With just a few days to go until the start of the season, what would be your starting 11 for the Leeds game with our current squad?

Here's mine, gone with Alnwick in goal as Allsop picked up an injury.


Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O'Dowda

Wintle Adams

Bowler Ramsey Robinson

Grant

I’d go with that too.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 7:55 pm

And me too

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 7:58 pm

Possibly Grant and Robinson switching, though they could do that during the game.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 9:41 pm

………….Alnwick……………….
Ng…Goutas…McGuiness…Collins
…………..Wintle………………..
Bowler…Ramsey…O’Dowda
…..Grant…Robinson………..


I’d play O’Dowda further forward.
It’s a crime playing him in defence.
Use him as an attacking threat.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 9:55 pm

Ketteringblues wrote:………….Alnwick……………….
Ng…Goutas…McGuiness…Collins
…………..Wintle………………..
Bowler…Ramsey…O’Dowda
…..Grant…Robinson………..


I’d play O’Dowda further forward.
It’s a crime playing him in defence.
Use him as an attacking threat.


A single player in midfield away at Leeds is certainly a choice

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 10:01 pm

Ketteringblues wrote:………….Alnwick……………….
Ng…Goutas…McGuiness…Collins
…………..Wintle………………..
Bowler…Ramsey…O’Dowda
…..Grant…Robinson………..


I’d play O’Dowda further forward.
It’s a crime playing him in defence.
Use him as an attacking threat.


Don't agree, think there's at least four better wingers at the club than O'Dowda. He should have a decent season at LB though, competing with Collins.

Agree with M4 Exile that one midfielder would be a disaster waiting to happen!

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 10:07 pm

…….Mc Guinness…. Goutas… NG
Bowler… Ojo… Wintle… O’Dowder
………………..Ramsey
…………Robinson…. Etete

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 10:15 pm

Rhydyfelin wrote:…….Mc Guinness…. Goutas… NG
Bowler… Ojo… Wintle… O’Dowder
………………..Ramsey
…………Robinson…. Etete


Ouch

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 10:21 pm

worcester_ccfc wrote:
Ketteringblues wrote:………….Alnwick……………….
Ng…Goutas…McGuiness…Collins
…………..Wintle………………..
Bowler…Ramsey…O’Dowda
…..Grant…Robinson………..


I’d play O’Dowda further forward.
It’s a crime playing him in defence.
Use him as an attacking threat.


Don't agree, think there's at least four better wingers at the club than O'Dowda. He should have a decent season at LB though, competing with Collins.

Agree with M4 Exile that one midfielder would be a disaster waiting to happen!


Single midfielder??
Wintle would be a defensive midfielder sitting in front of the back 4, with Rambo, Bowler and O’Dowda the midfield.
O’Dowda is one of the very few attacking threats we have, so I question putting him in defence and miles away from the opposition goal. Collins is also a better defender.
You could have played Robinson or Grant out wide with just the 1 up top, but for me, Robinson plays better with someone to play off.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 10:39 pm

Ketteringblues wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:
Ketteringblues wrote:………….Alnwick……………….
Ng…Goutas…McGuiness…Collins
…………..Wintle………………..
Bowler…Ramsey…O’Dowda
…..Grant…Robinson………..


I’d play O’Dowda further forward.
It’s a crime playing him in defence.
Use him as an attacking threat.


Don't agree, think there's at least four better wingers at the club than O'Dowda. He should have a decent season at LB though, competing with Collins.

Agree with M4 Exile that one midfielder would be a disaster waiting to happen!


Single midfielder??
Wintle would be a defensive midfielder sitting in front of the back 4, with Rambo, Bowler and O’Dowda the midfield.
O’Dowda is one of the very few attacking threats we have, so I question putting him in defence and miles away from the opposition goal. Collins is also a better defender.
You could have played Robinson or Grant out wide with just the 1 up top, but for me, Robinson plays better with someone to play off.


For a start, it's obvious we'll be playing 4-2-3-1.

The way that team looks, if they had a counter attack then only Wintle would stand in their way in front of the defence. They'd score five or six goals.

O'Dowda will play as a LB. Last season when people wanted him on the wing was different because we didn't have better options, but we do now. Like I said, at least four better wingers now.

Goals and assists over the last three seasons:

Grant - 22 goals, 6 assists

Robinson - 12 goals, 15 assists

Bowler - 11 goals, 5 assists

Meite - 4 goals, 3 assists

O'Dowda - 5 goals, 4 assists


So of those four, O'Dowda only has more goal involvements than Meite (by 2) - who didn't play many games the season before last because of injuries.

He will be a LB.



Collins is still coming back from a big injury. I don't think he's ready to start Championship games for a few weeks yet. When he is, him and O'Dowda will compete for that position.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 10:41 pm

I would play 4 at the back and 6 forward as we never have a midfield when a counter attack happens, we have a corner they win the ball then they are outside our penalty area. We have 4 defenders and a goalie they should be able to deal with it. Having 6 up front give them plenty to worry about.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 10:55 pm

Allsop (if not injured)
NG McGuiness Koutas Collins
Wintle Ralls
Rambo
Bowler Robinson Grant

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Wed Aug 02, 2023 11:43 pm

For what it’s worth I think it’s too soon for Bowler to come straight in. What I think he’ll probably go with is:

Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O’Dowda

Wintle Ralls

Ojo Ramsey Grant

Ugbo

What I would go with:

Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness Collins

Rinomhota Ralls

Robinson Ramsey O’Dowda

Grant

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 7:26 am

Ketteringblues wrote:………….Alnwick……………….
Ng…Goutas…McGuiness…Collins
…………..Wintle………………..
Bowler…Ramsey…O’Dowda
…..Grant…Robinson………..


I’d play O’Dowda further forward.
It’s a crime playing him in defence.
Use him as an attacking threat.


Training and pre-season is all about learning the formation and tactics the Gaffer wants to play and I can assure you it won't be that one otherwise we'd have seen it before now.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 8:19 am

My choice would be;

Alnwick
Ng / Goutas / McGuinness(Or Panzo if he signs) / Collins
Wintle / Adams
Bowler / Ramsey / Robinson
Grant

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 9:37 am

worcester_ccfc wrote:With just a few days to go until the start of the season, what would be your starting 11 for the Leeds game with our current squad?

Here's mine, gone with Alnwick in goal as Allsop picked up an injury.


.............Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O'Dowda

......Wintle Adams

Bowler Ramsey Robinson

Grant


Based on pre season, I think it will be


...........Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O'Dowda

.........Wintle Ralls

Bowler ...Ramsey .....Grant

...........Robinson

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 9:42 am

Bluebina wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:With just a few days to go until the start of the season, what would be your starting 11 for the Leeds game with our current squad?

Here's mine, gone with Alnwick in goal as Allsop picked up an injury.


.............Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O'Dowda

......Wintle Adams

Bowler Ramsey Robinson

Grant


Based on pre season, I think it will be


...........Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O'Dowda

.........Wintle Ralls

Bowler ...Ramsey .....Grant

...........Robinson



Thats assuming Bowler comes in fit and impresses early if not he may go with Ojo he seems to like him.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 10:12 am

Bluebina wrote:
Bluebina wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:With just a few days to go until the start of the season, what would be your starting 11 for the Leeds game with our current squad?

Here's mine, gone with Alnwick in goal as Allsop picked up an injury.


.............Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O'Dowda

......Wintle Adams

Bowler Ramsey Robinson

Grant


Based on pre season, I think it will be


...........Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O'Dowda

.........Wintle Ralls

Bowler ...Ramsey .....Grant

...........Robinson



Thats assuming Bowler comes in fit and impresses early if not he may go with Ojo he seems to like him.

How are Ralls / McGuinesx injuries? Any updates?
EB seemed to indicate that both would be training this week so I’d imagine both would be in.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 12:26 pm

.........................Allsop. (*)

NG........Goutas.....Mc Guinness....... Collins (/)

......................Wintle.....Rino.

Bowler............. Ramsey...........O'Dowda

.......................... Grant.


(*) - If not injured.
(/) - If match fit.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 12:34 pm

Caerdydd12 wrote:.........................Allsop. (*)

NG........Goutas.....Mc Guinness....... Collins (/)

......................Wintle.....Rino.

Bowler............. Ramsey...........O'Dowda

.......................... Grant.


(*) - If not injured.
(/) - If match fit.




We shouldn't overlook Rino to be honest, as we will need his physicality in midfield.
Also it was a tough call between Robbo and Grant up top, I'd start with Grant as stats go in his favour and he will want to get his first goal(s) for us :bluebird:

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 3:05 pm

Caerdydd12 wrote:
Caerdydd12 wrote:.........................Allsop. (*)

NG........Goutas.....Mc Guinness....... Collins (/)

......................Wintle.....Rino.

Bowler............. Ramsey...........O'Dowda

.......................... Grant.


(*) - If not injured.
(/) - If match fit.




We shouldn't overlook Rino to be honest, as we will need his physicality in midfield.
Also it was a tough call between Robbo and Grant up top, I'd start with Grant as stats go in his favour and he will want to get his first goal(s) for us :bluebird:

Personally think rhino had a shocking preseason, sloppy in possession and gave the ball away too often.
Always thought last season his best games were as a sub too

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 3:24 pm

bluebirdoct1962 wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:With just a few days to go until the start of the season, what would be your starting 11 for the Leeds game with our current squad?

Here's mine, gone with Alnwick in goal as Allsop picked up an injury.


Alnwick

Ng Goutas McGuinness O'Dowda

Wintle Adams

Bowler Ramsey Robinson

Grant

I’d go with that too.

I'd go with that too, guys; but at the start of the season and with so many new players we have allow the new manager to dabble a bit until he finds his settled XI and formation...

I'm hooeful of a decent start but the season doesn't end after a few games... :ayatollah:

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 4:05 pm

Ryan Allsop is injured and will miss Leeds but everyone else is available.

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 4:33 pm

worcester_ccfc wrote:Ryan Allsop is injured and will miss Leeds but everyone else is available.

Ralls or Adams?
Think I’d go for JR, purely on experience as EA did well v Wycombe

Re: " Team for Leeds?

Thu Aug 03, 2023 4:35 pm

bluebirdoct1962 wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:Ryan Allsop is injured and will miss Leeds but everyone else is available.

Ralls or Adams?
Think I’d go for JR, purely on experience as EA did well v Wycombe


Adams would be my choice but in truth either would be understandable.