Is Dalman wrong?

For saying we are close to signing a game changing midfielder but it’s 50/50?

I think it should be kept quiet until it happens.

It just gets Cardiff fans hopes up to more than likely be disappointed. I do think they should keep everything quiet until it’s been officially signed.

He may be trying to big up the player to get them to sign by saying how good they are but it may completely flop.

Totally agree. Say nothing until a player has signed

I think he's right. Nothing wrong with getting fans a bit more excited.

When he gets the deal done, and I think he's probably more confident than 50/50 privately, that will be proven.

I think he's right. Nothing wrong with getting fans a bit more excited.

When he gets the deal done, and I think he's probably more confident than 50/50 privately, that will be proven.

I agree.

Totally agree. Say nothing until a player has signed

Agree - We have now had at least 3 broken promises in the last 5 weeks from the D Man / club / manager