Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

“ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 3:54 pm

Get them off ASAP

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 5:49 pm

I think you can ad NG to that list

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 5:54 pm

Backtoblue wrote:I think you can ad NG to that list


Ridiculous

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 6:04 pm

Why ridiculous watch his play ....lost possession in middle of field leaving goutas exposed for their first goal ...put pressure on our midfield with his many underhit passes out of defence ...and turned his back on their goalscorer for their second goal

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 6:07 pm

No. You're seeing it from your point of view. Not only was he better than most today... Over the season, he's been great. But hey... Let's drop him?!

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 6:18 pm

In your opinion he's been great ...in my opinion he's been poor ....we're both entitled to our opinion...and my opinion is get rid

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 6:19 pm

Backtoblue wrote:In your opinion he's been great ...in my opinion he's been poor ....we're both entitled to our opinion...and my opinion is get rid


Ok.

Get rid of one of our most consistent players.

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 6:44 pm

You reckon he's consistent watch him closely in our next couple of fixtures and if he surprises me and does well I will be the first to admit I was wrong

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 6:46 pm

Backtoblue wrote:You reckon he's consistent watch him closely in our next couple of fixtures and if he surprises me and does well I will be the first to admit I was wrong


So the previous 20 games counts for f**k all?

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 6:51 pm

You said he's been consistent for the season I disagree with you I think he has not been good enough like I said were all entitled to our opinion

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 6:52 pm

jimmy_rat wrote:
Backtoblue wrote:You reckon he's consistent watch him closely in our next couple of fixtures and if he surprises me and does well I will be the first to admit I was wrong


So the previous 20 games counts for f**k all?


NG had a good game, I think this backtoblue is in the minority.
Only a few posts too so could just be a WUM. :shock: :roll:

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 7:03 pm

Immaterial if it is only a few posts I guarantee you I am not a Wum this board is opinion based and that is my opinion and I have supported city long enough to be able to give my opinion whether it be on this board or not

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 8:18 pm

Backtoblue wrote:Why ridiculous watch his play ....lost possession in middle of field leaving goutas exposed for their first goal ...put pressure on our midfield with his many underhit passes out of defence ...and turned his back on their goalscorer for their second goal



Have to agree with you but who have we got to replace him .

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 8:27 pm

Backtoblue wrote:I think you can ad NG to that list

One of our best players today, ridiculous

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 8:48 pm

I think ng is entitled to have a few mistakes from time to time considering how class he has been ,
One of our best players no doubt
He would be my first pick in a team

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 9:11 pm

Goutas was to blame for the goal he rushed out and completely missed his man and got done

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 9:38 pm

Ng is ok, but goal came from his side and his crossing is awful

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 9:42 pm

Ng has set high standards for himself and didn’t quite meet them today. But I wouldn’t pick him out as one of the worst players like I did these four at half time.

I do think he should be taken off free kicks now though. He’s scored a few but think we have better options than him, such as Turnbull and Ramsey (when he’s back up to match sharpness).

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 9:54 pm

I would quite happily see a totally different team on the field next game.
Swap the keep out.
Swap NG with Romeo
Drop Goutas for McGuiness
Swap Collins for this new Man City lad
Drop Bowler as he’s becoming a one trick pony with no plan B.
Get Colwill Rambo and Turnbull in the middle of the park.
Get Grant playing upfront instead of Etete as he’s absolute crap.
Give Tanner another crack.

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 10:31 pm

taff555 wrote:I would quite happily see a totally different team on the field next game.
Swap the keep out.
Swap NG with Romeo
Drop Goutas for McGuiness
Swap Collins for this new Man City lad
Drop Bowler as he’s becoming a one trick pony with no plan B.
Get Colwill Rambo and Turnbull in the middle of the park.
Get Grant playing upfront instead of Etete as he’s absolute crap.
Give Tanner another crack.


Agree on some. Question you on others.
Tell me what has Alnwick done wrong?
Over 10+ games history is Romeo better than Ng?
What’s Goutas done wrong?
Agree, drop bowler.
Agree on the Rambo, Turnbull, Colwell midfield
Missing the love for grant. No bottle in 50/50 challenges and not enough end result with him.
Tanner is brain dead. Skill on the ball going forward, but off the ball like fish out of water-not a scooobie.

Re: “ Collins, Etete, Wintle & Bowler “

Sat Feb 10, 2024 11:42 pm

Cant see how we can drop NG, he looks good most games, didnt see what happened for first goal properly seemed he was out of position, NG likes to come inside a bit as inverted full back.

NG also one of the few players who will get stuck in and give it some

Philips looked really classy at times reads the game really well i thought

I like Grant goes all game no bullshit from him, i thought he get near double digits this season, end product is lacking but hes one of our better players.

Bowler does my f*cking head in, he kinda sits inside, never back and never forward, dont over lap. Wants the ball to his feet and defenders to come ot him so he can try dribble past.

It looks great when he does it but he cant cross either, and he does it 1 in 5 games once.

What i find with City is after a bit the other team gets confidence and they all move up, quite a few times today they had 10 in our half, they looked like the home team