Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

What has Schnacher achieved ?

Fri Sep 27, 2024 7:28 am

I appreciate he got Plymouth promoted but that was mainly down to Ryan Lowe and then he gets the bullet from Stoke

Re: What has Schnacher achieved ?

Fri Sep 27, 2024 7:32 am

Mr Moo Cow wrote:I appreciate he got Plymouth promoted but that was mainly down to Ryan Lowe and then he gets the bullet from Stoke


Spell check does my head in Schumacher

Re: What has Schnacher achieved ?

Fri Sep 27, 2024 7:52 am

I can’t see how you can say he got Plymouth promoted on the back of Ryan Lowe, as after Lowe he completely changed the teams way of playing and it was a full season after Lowe left that he got them promoted.

For me the reason I want Schumacher is how he set up the team to play attacking football, has a plan A, B & C adapts to different formations when needed, his overall style of play is opposite to Bulut’s which is what most if not all fans wants.

And of all the available managers out there then he is the best suited currently.

I think maybe Lowe is also available, but isn’t mentioned at all on here, perhaps it’s because he left Preston after 1 game of the season, which would not be good for any team or fan base as it seems a waste of a transfer window and pre season ?

Who is your realistic choice for the role ?

Re: What has Schnacher achieved ?

Fri Sep 27, 2024 9:19 am

I think its less about achievement and more playing style, it's alot better than what we have been getting to be fair

I wouldn't be mad if he joined us

Re: What has Schnacher achieved ?

Fri Sep 27, 2024 9:41 am

Welsh Exile wrote:I can’t see how you can say he got Plymouth promoted on the back of Ryan Lowe, as after Lowe he completely changed the teams way of playing and it was a full season after Lowe left that he got them promoted.

For me the reason I want Schumacher is how he set up the team to play attacking football, has a plan A, B & C adapts to different formations when needed, his overall style of play is opposite to Bulut’s which is what most if not all fans wants.

And of all the available managers out there then he is the best suited currently.

I think maybe Lowe is also available, but isn’t mentioned at all on here, perhaps it’s because he left Preston after 1 game of the season, which would not be good for any team or fan base as it seems a waste of a transfer window and pre season ?

Who is your realistic choice for the role ?


Its just my opinion, Stoke got shot quickly for whatever reason

The problem with next manager with the present regime we cant attract good candidates

If fit and well I would probably go for Mowbray

Re: What has Schnacher achieved ?

Fri Sep 27, 2024 10:00 am

Mr Moo Cow wrote:
Welsh Exile wrote:I can’t see how you can say he got Plymouth promoted on the back of Ryan Lowe, as after Lowe he completely changed the teams way of playing and it was a full season after Lowe left that he got them promoted.

For me the reason I want Schumacher is how he set up the team to play attacking football, has a plan A, B & C adapts to different formations when needed, his overall style of play is opposite to Bulut’s which is what most if not all fans wants.

And of all the available managers out there then he is the best suited currently.

I think maybe Lowe is also available, but isn’t mentioned at all on here, perhaps it’s because he left Preston after 1 game of the season, which would not be good for any team or fan base as it seems a waste of a transfer window and pre season ?

Who is your realistic choice for the role ?


Its just my opinion, Stoke got shot quickly for whatever reason

The problem with next manager with the present regime we cant attract good candidates

If fit and well I would probably go for Mowbray



To be fair mate stoke fans where fuming about his sack and confused

Re: What has Schnacher achieved ?

Fri Sep 27, 2024 11:10 am

Out of the available ones out there as you have probably guessed my first choice is Schumacher however if we can’t or don’t get him Mowbury would be a great shout as long as his health is ok, again he likes attacking football and is an excellent man manger.