Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

What is your team for Saturday

Thu Nov 07, 2024 6:38 pm

My team for saturday would be

Alnwick
Ng
Goutas
Daland
Bagan
Robertson
Turnbull
Colwill
Tannar
O’Dowda
Robinson

Subs
Horvath/ Chambers/ Fish/ El Ghazi/ Rinomhota/ Willock / Ashford/ Reindorf, / and T. George

If robinson is unfit then I would start with Reindorf and have Etete as one of the substitutes

I would also tell Alnwick to stop messing around with the ball and get it to our midfield as quickly as possible so it gives our forwards some chance of attacking

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Thu Nov 07, 2024 6:47 pm

rontom wrote:My team for saturday would be

Alnwick
Ng
Goutas
Daland
Bagan
Robertson
Turnbull
Colwill
Tannar
O’Dowda
Robinson

Subs
Horvath/ Chambers/ Fish/ El Ghazi/ Rinomhota/ Willock / Ashford/ Reindorf, / and T. George

If robinson is unfit then I would start with Reindorf and have Etete as one of the substitutes

I would also tell Alnwick to stop messing around with the ball and get it to our midfield as quickly as possible so it gives our forwards some chance of attacking


Drop Chambers when he’s been arguably one of our best of late?

I stopped reading after that.

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Thu Nov 07, 2024 6:57 pm

Roath_Blue wrote:
rontom wrote:My team for saturday would be

Alnwick
Ng
Goutas
Daland
Bagan
Robertson
Turnbull
Colwill
Tannar
O’Dowda
Robinson

Subs
Horvath/ Chambers/ Fish/ El Ghazi/ Rinomhota/ Willock / Ashford/ Reindorf, / and T. George

If robinson is unfit then I would start with Reindorf and have Etete as one of the substitutes

I would also tell Alnwick to stop messing around with the ball and get it to our midfield as quickly as possible so it gives our forwards some chance of attacking


Drop Chambers when he’s been arguably one of our best of late?

I stopped reading after that.


But he is not, in MY OPINION, better than Daland, and that's why I dropped him, what's your team then? and I promise you I will have the decency to read all of it, not make snide remarks like you have

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Thu Nov 07, 2024 7:00 pm

rontom wrote:
Roath_Blue wrote:
rontom wrote:My team for saturday would be

Alnwick
Ng
Goutas
Daland
Bagan
Robertson
Turnbull
Colwill
Tannar
O’Dowda
Robinson

Subs
Horvath/ Chambers/ Fish/ El Ghazi/ Rinomhota/ Willock / Ashford/ Reindorf, / and T. George

If robinson is unfit then I would start with Reindorf and have Etete as one of the substitutes

I would also tell Alnwick to stop messing around with the ball and get it to our midfield as quickly as possible so it gives our forwards some chance of attacking


Drop Chambers when he’s been arguably one of our best of late?

I stopped reading after that.


But he is not, in MY OPINION, better than Daland, and that's why I dropped him, what's your team then? and I promise you I will have the decency to read all of it, not make snide remarks like you have


It’s not about just best players as a singular.

It’s about a partnership which has worked very well. Why change that partnership?

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Thu Nov 07, 2024 7:01 pm

rontom wrote:
Roath_Blue wrote:
rontom wrote:My team for saturday would be

Alnwick
Ng
Goutas
Daland
Bagan
Robertson
Turnbull
Colwill
Tannar
O’Dowda
Robinson

Subs
Horvath/ Chambers/ Fish/ El Ghazi/ Rinomhota/ Willock / Ashford/ Reindorf, / and T. George

If robinson is unfit then I would start with Reindorf and have Etete as one of the substitutes

I would also tell Alnwick to stop messing around with the ball and get it to our midfield as quickly as possible so it gives our forwards some chance of attacking


Drop Chambers when he’s been arguably one of our best of late?

I stopped reading after that.


But he is not, in MY OPINION, better than Daland, and that's why I dropped him, what's your team then? and I promise you I will have the decency to read all of it, not make snide remarks like you have


It’s not about just best players as a singular.

It’s about a partnership which has worked very well. Why change that partnership?

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Thu Nov 07, 2024 7:09 pm

Roath_Blue wrote:
rontom wrote:
Roath_Blue wrote:
rontom wrote:My team for saturday would be

Alnwick
Ng
Goutas
Daland
Bagan
Robertson
Turnbull
Colwill
Tannar
O’Dowda
Robinson

Subs
Horvath/ Chambers/ Fish/ El Ghazi/ Rinomhota/ Willock / Ashford/ Reindorf, / and T. George

If robinson is unfit then I would start with Reindorf and have Etete as one of the substitutes

I would also tell Alnwick to stop messing around with the ball and get it to our midfield as quickly as possible so it gives our forwards some chance of attacking


Drop Chambers when he’s been arguably one of our best of late?

I stopped reading after that.


But he is not, in MY OPINION, better than Daland, and that's why I dropped him, what's your team then? and I promise you I will have the decency to read all of it, not make snide remarks like you have


It’s not about just best players as a singular.

It’s about a partnership which has worked very well. Why change that partnership?


That's fair enough, but if it benefits the team, then yes, change it. As an example, the Colwill and Tanner partnership was good but if there was anyone better in the squad, I would, without any doubt, change it, it is called progress

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Thu Nov 07, 2024 9:09 pm

Alnwick
Ng Chambers Goutas O'Dowda
Robertson Turnbull
Tanner Colwill Willock
Robinson


El Ghazi needs to be dropped, might give him more motivation to play better.

Chambers is undroppable, playing very well. Harsh on Daland but he'll get his chance when form drops or when there are injuries/suspensions.

Robertson being back will be a huge plus.

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Thu Nov 07, 2024 10:47 pm

Good team there Worcester. One slight change for me though. Bagan at left back and O’Dowda left side midfield. The latter is so good going forward.
We have to go at them from the off on Saturday. We want to be well off the bottom 3 before the internationals break :bluescarf: :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Fri Nov 08, 2024 8:22 am

Brezza wrote:Good team there Worcester. One slight change for me though. Bagan at left back and O’Dowda left side midfield. The latter is so good going forward.
We have to go at them from the off on Saturday. We want to be well off the bottom 3 before the internationals break :bluescarf: :ayatollah: :ayatollah:


So you would pick the same team as me, except for Chambers instead of Daland.

I would have to change the substitutes because I forgot about the u21 playing their cup game away to Everton tonight.
I believe that we should have at least two u21 players on the bench where possible for every match.

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Fri Nov 08, 2024 10:17 am

Alnwick
Ng
Chambers
Goutas
O'Dowda
Robertson
Turnbull
Colwill
Tanner
ElGhazi
Robinson

Our current strongest 11, for me. A defence that finally look settled which made me eat my words a few weeks back that O'Dowda wasn't a LB. ElGhazi is on thin ice, but I think O'Dowda's overlap is better when ElGhazi is playing as he had the brain to pull his man inside for O'Dowda to overlap.

Robertson as a must.

Re: What is your team for Saturday

Fri Nov 08, 2024 11:21 am

rontom wrote:My team for saturday would be

Alnwick
Ng
Goutas
Daland
Bagan
Robertson
Turnbull
Colwill
Tannar
O’Dowda
Robinson

Subs
Horvath/ Chambers/ Fish/ El Ghazi/ Rinomhota/ Willock / Ashford/ Reindorf, / and T. George

If robinson is unfit then I would start with Reindorf and have Etete as one of the substitutes

I would also tell Alnwick to stop messing around with the ball and get it to our midfield as quickly as possible so it gives our forwards some chance of attacking


I’d just change willock for Elgazi.