Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Schumacher Time

Sun Mar 09, 2025 8:11 pm

It should have been schumacher time last time we were without a manager, and he should be brought in now to save us from going down and to build for the future. And if we go down and he dont get bolton up this season then we should go for him then too to try and get us back up.

He would have been my first choice before we hired riza. He is flying with bolton in league 1,lot of experience as a manager, proven promotions,championship experience, nothing our current rookie riza got who i fear will take us down now because he got no previous experience or know how how to get us out of this mess.

Re: Schumacher Time

Sun Mar 09, 2025 8:15 pm

Why would he leave Bolton?

Re: Schumacher Time

Sun Mar 09, 2025 8:16 pm

He was my first choice - but it's not happening.

They had the chance to bring in an experienced manager at the back end of next year. They didn't do it.

They wouldn't do it then so they're not going to do it now or in the summer.

Those calling for Riza to go, and I know you're not one of them, are living in some cuckoo land where they believe we'll bring in a top manager. Not happening.

I still back Riza because I do believe he can take us forward with the right summer signings but also because the replacement would be worse - whoever it is, it won't be a manager with experience.

Re: Schumacher Time

Mon Mar 10, 2025 12:48 am

How many experienced managers are there in bottom 7? Because They all can't be inexperienced and they're not doing their clubs any more good than riza.

Re: Schumacher Time

Mon Mar 10, 2025 8:28 pm

but thats the point riza not exactly pulling up trees if he was we be saying what a great appointment hes been which his record shows hes not

Re: Schumacher Time

Mon Mar 10, 2025 11:24 pm

desbluebird wrote:but thats the point riza not exactly pulling up trees if he was we be saying what a great appointment hes been which his record shows hes not



He was never a great appointment and time as proved that... but the OP point is we should get in an experienced coach now! But
That hasn't worked for clubs who have Been near bottom all season
So why would it work at city? Yes got good squad but all managers have ways of playing so would the squad adapt to new coach quickly enough to get out of trouble that's the 64k dollar question?

Re: Schumacher Time

Tue Mar 11, 2025 7:19 am

Some managers have an immediate impact. Warnock always did as he was a really good man manager. Rowett has done the same at Oxford. Some take a bit more time to impact.

Re: Schumacher Time

Tue Mar 11, 2025 2:19 pm

Lets be honest, is Schumacher had the job and we were in the same position we'd get the same comments, Hes only hired as he is a yes man, he was a cheap option etc.

Re: Schumacher Time

Tue Mar 11, 2025 2:41 pm

bluebird04 wrote:Lets be honest, is Schumacher had the job and we were in the same position we'd get the same comments, Hes only hired as he is a yes man, he was a cheap option etc.


Look I hate Tan & his cronies as much as the next man but isn't every manager at every club ultimately a "yes man" as they can all be fired at the behest of the owner? All this "yes man" bs being used as an insult is just that, bs. Even Warnock was a "yes man" because if he wanted to spend on a player he didn't just get to spend whatever he wanted & had to go to Tan & explain why he wanted a particular player.

Re: Schumacher Time

Tue Mar 11, 2025 2:50 pm

worcester_ccfc wrote:He was my first choice - but it's not happening.

They had the chance to bring in an experienced manager at the back end of next year. They didn't do it.

They wouldn't do it then so they're not going to do it now or in the summer.

Those calling for Riza to go, and I know you're not one of them, are living in some cuckoo land where they believe we'll bring in a top manager. Not happening.

I still back Riza because I do believe he can take us forward with the right summer signings but also because the replacement would be worse - whoever it is, it won't be a manager with experience.


I agree with you mate, Riza could be a safer bet keeping us up, but its still a gamble keeping him to try do it, and for me when they hired him it was a big gamble then, but just cheaper easier option from the owners which shows no ambition. If i was betting, i would bet on an experienced manager to come in now and keep us up before betting on riza who is inexperienced.

Re: Schumacher Time

Tue Mar 11, 2025 2:52 pm

Welshman in CA wrote:
bluebird04 wrote:Lets be honest, is Schumacher had the job and we were in the same position we'd get the same comments, Hes only hired as he is a yes man, he was a cheap option etc.


Look I hate Tan & his cronies as much as the next man but isn't every manager at every club ultimately a "yes man" as they can all be fired at the behest of the owner? All this "yes man" bs being used as an insult is just that, bs. Even Warnock was a "yes man" because if he wanted to spend on a player he didn't just get to spend whatever he wanted & had to go to Tan & explain why he wanted a particular player.


Good post and completely agree.

Re: Schumacher Time

Tue Mar 11, 2025 4:02 pm

Welshman in CA wrote:
bluebird04 wrote:Lets be honest, is Schumacher had the job and we were in the same position we'd get the same comments, Hes only hired as he is a yes man, he was a cheap option etc.


Look I hate Tan & his cronies as much as the next man but isn't every manager at every club ultimately a "yes man" as they can all be fired at the behest of the owner? All this "yes man" bs being used as an insult is just that, bs. Even Warnock was a "yes man" because if he wanted to spend on a player he didn't just get to spend whatever he wanted & had to go to Tan & explain why he wanted a particular player.


That's my point, just not as well written as what you said, regardless of whom we hire. We would get the same comments on this forum saying he's yes man, a cheap option etc. It doesn't matter who's hired we'd get the same comments.