Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Tue Apr 08, 2025 8:43 pm

Please don' t play 5 at the back again this season to many getting in each others way what a wasted 1st 45 mins sitting back we need points attack attack attack no more 5 at the back.

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Tue Apr 08, 2025 8:46 pm

You need two athletes either side of a slower centre half for this to work and we don't have that. Daland is lost in a 3

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Tue Apr 08, 2025 8:53 pm

We don't have the players to do it well enough.

That's been shown time and time again so no idea why he set us up like that tonight.

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Tue Apr 08, 2025 9:00 pm

I think everyone called it when the line up was announced. The team cant play it. At least he changed to 4 at the back at half time. Give him some credit for the switch but it's like playing with 10 men with Riza in charge.

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Tue Apr 08, 2025 9:34 pm

DisasterLand shouldn’t be anywhere near the first team squad. Fish has improved recently, Goutas unfortunately now prone to too many errors. Give Bagan a go (at least he has pace) or play Ng at centre back for a bit more mettle in the tackle.

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Tue Apr 08, 2025 9:37 pm

ALL out attack on Saturday no excuses no more bullshit we are the home team time to play like we are

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Tue Apr 08, 2025 11:19 pm

i cant give him credit should never had that formation in the first place look the guys over the moon with a draw it seems hes bragging about 4 undefeated seriously its a terrible record two wins away all season our goals against is terrible yet we do have some decent players just he cant play them because he doesnt want to lose if we score first he will still change it to hold on to what we got sorry hes a no from me sooner hes gone the better i will feel

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Wed Apr 09, 2025 1:01 am

We will go 5 at the back every game and lose or draw if lucky I think everyone’s given up hope now , Dalman is meeting Annis and Jonny L so the protest is off. There is no fight left. wtf is Riza doing to stay in this job. I fking cannot stand the guy anymore. He’s seen a weakness at our club and has snuck in to get a pay check. Fking Riza the rat. After watching that game I’m questioning why I support this club it’s not our club anymore, It belongs to a bunch of jokers . I need to seriously find a way to stop caring and get away from it. Probably won’t happen but I need to for the health.

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Wed Apr 09, 2025 7:43 am

O'Dowda has one of his worst games in a Cardiff shirt last night.

Daland and Goutas are awful.

I thought Rino & Fish had two of the better performances.

Collectively, if you play all of the above, AND Mannesverk AND Chambers.... then you simply cannot be as open as we were at the back. 7 defensive unit meant we were sitting ducks, but surprisingly able to get cut open at will (against a shite side)

A number of stupid errors by all also, just shows that they are playing in absolute fear.

Riza needs to relax them, realise that the above doesn't work, and stop us leaking goals!!

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Wed Apr 09, 2025 7:47 am

montyblue wrote:Please don' t play 5 at the back again this season to many getting in each others way what a wasted 1st 45 mins sitting back we need points attack attack attack no more 5 at the back.


5 at the back can work and be an attacking formation with the right players and coach.

But I agree with you we should definitely dump that idea at our club.

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Wed Apr 09, 2025 8:44 am

the worst thing about going 5 at the back against Preston is we have actually scored more goals than them this season, so why would he be scared of them

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Wed Apr 09, 2025 8:47 am

5 at the back doesn't make us stronger defensively.

The players are always out of position because it is overcrowded.

Plus, it makes us weaker in midfield and invites more pressure.

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Wed Apr 09, 2025 10:29 am

I agree, we have far too many talented midfielders to be playing a back five. The only time I have seen it work is when Perry and Bagan played there with Fish in the centre against Plymouth, this is because they both have pace. But overall we should stick to a four.

The same old problem is I don't think anyone knows what our best back four is. Darland has looked awful since coming back from injury, so I would either have to say Fish and Goutas or Fish and Bagan. Although Rino and O'Dowda are out of position they seem to be our best options there at the minute but there is a lack of continuity as we constantly chop and change. No wonder we are leaky and disjointed.

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Wed Apr 09, 2025 10:32 am

Blue Valley wrote:5 at the back doesn't make us stronger defensively.

The players are always out of position because it is overcrowded.

Plus, it makes us weaker in midfield and invites more pressure.


Exactly mate. The defensive coaches must have just said, 'put bodies in there'. Crazy!!!

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Wed Apr 09, 2025 10:42 am

Players we got suit 4-1-2-3 . We really need our wingers to get balls into the box to Salech, also we need our full backs to put in some deep swinging crosses like PNE second goal last night. Its not really rocket science.

The hard decision is picking Cham or Manv as DM

Re: 5 AT THE BACK NEVER AGAIN

Wed Apr 09, 2025 10:56 am

Logie wrote:Players we got suit 4-1-2-3 . We really need our wingers to get balls into the box to Salech, also we need our full backs to put in some deep swinging crosses like PNE second goal last night. Its not really rocket science.

The hard decision is picking Cham or Manv as DM


My mate and I had EXACTLY the same conversation last night; including about 1 defensive midfielder.