is adam mathews that good?

watching todays game and he gave the ball away alot .if we get anywhere near 4 million we should bite there hands off anyone else agree?

Ummm, he wasn't playing in his position, and he was probably playing a formation he hasn't played before, with players he hasn't played with.

Bit harsh to judge him on today's performance.

yes a very good player with so much potential for a young player

deffo worth at least 4 million

Ummm, he wasn't playing in his position, and he was probably playing a formation he hasn't played before, with players he hasn't played with.

Bit harsh to judge him on today's performance.

Agree - would you judge Chopra after 45 mins as a left back? i think not. give the lad a chance - he was well out of position and it has proved Jones is off his f*cking trolley - please remove PR & DJ as quickly as humanly possible.......

Don't judge him on today's game. When he and Burke play together they are magic. They bring out the best in each other. IMO he is very good and worth £5M

Ummm, he wasn't playing in his position, and he was probably playing a formation he hasn't played before, with players he hasn't played with.

Bit harsh to judge him on today's performance.

not just todays game but he does give the ball away alot first half agiainst forest! i hope the lad proves me wrong but i cant se anything special other than hes so young take the money i say i just hope no scouts were there today watching or we are fcuked

were these the only two games you been to mate the lad is quality and atleast he didn shy away from trying to ta take control of the game hes also a right back and dave jones put him in centre mid of what i could see.and he done more in the time he was on than rae an ledley done all game

The lad has got all the attributes to be a great modern day full back. Comfortable in possession, loves getting forward, great pace and can also defend well.

were these the only two games you been to mate the lad is quality and atleast he didn shy away from trying to ta take control of the game hes also a right back and dave jones put him in centre mid of what i could see.and he done more in the time he was on than rae an ledley done all game

i havnt missed a game in years m8 i just dont think hes good enough yet ,he wouldnt get in to any of the top premiership teams ,gunter was the same went to early,if the money is there we got take it but i think he will end up back in the championship prefer if he stayed with us and developed

Don't judge him on today's game. When he and Burke play together they are magic. They bring out the best in each other. IMO he is very good and worth £5M

Make that £7.5m as Burke would obviously have to go with him

i think the kid is gonna be special thats my opinion.when fergie and wenger come knockin you know theres something there like with ramsey.but as you say would be great if he stayed and learnt his trade with us for couple of seasons!!!!