Why do people rate Jay..?

In my opinion he's an average player at this level and will never set the game alight.

Because he is sat on his arse more than he is kicking or heading the ball.

In my opinion he's an average player at this level and will never set the game alight.

I agree with you, he seems to have this "greater than tho" attitude as well. If he could possibly spend time on his feet then perhaps we can judge him better, however I have a feeling we wont be seeing Jay in a City shirt by the end of January.

i dont, just falls over at the slightest touch

I can see why people get frustrated with Jay (doesnt stand up in the challenge etc) but I do believe he is an asset we need to keep hold of.

Does anyone have any stats on how we've done in the games he's played in against games missed?

i think he's got bags of talent but it's his attitude thats suspect some games he just doesn't seem interested, but when he's in the mood he's our most important player his goal down the liberty for example pure class under pressure.

-Skillful
-Strong on the ball
-Great technique
-Dedicated
-Fast
-Non-selfish

He also has a very good attitude towards the game, brilliant player and would do well for a team like Villa - who he's linked with.

He is a useful player for this league, this is his level though. I must say, he isn't a very likeable character is he?

He's a divisive character and a bit on the arrogant side. I think we're a better team when he's playing and he's got excellent instinct, but I think we're now finding out why he's had so many clubs

He is a good time Charlie, he wore a scarf around his neck today lol, to keep him warm .

jay is a major part to the way we play
id bet that pretty much every team in the championship would want him if they could afford him
yeah he falls over and doesnt seem to give 100% everytime, but he is a pain for defenders

jay is a major part to the way we play
id bet that pretty much every team in the championship would want him if they could afford him
yeah he falls over and doesnt seem to give 100% everytime, but he is a pain for defenders

So was Fortune West, but I just dont rate him, only my opinion, he is not consistant.

jay is a major part to the way we play
id bet that pretty much every team in the championship would want him if they could afford him
yeah he falls over and doesnt seem to give 100% everytime, but he is a pain for defenders

So was Fortune West, but I just dont rate him, only my opinion, he is not consistant.

everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and personally i think he is a massive part of the side,

at the risk of making a fool of myself, please tell me he did not have a scarf on

at the risk of making a fool of myself, please tell me he did not have a scarf on

Yes, played the whole game with it on, the Scunthorpe players were laughing about it.

what a bloody poof, prima donars my arse

The guy is an absolute fairy there is no doubt about it but he is still one of our most important players.One of the most naturally gifted footballers at the club and the player we miss most when he's not playing.

If you could combine the hunger and determination of Chops with the ability of Bothroyd you'd have the dream striker.......then again he would'nt playing for us then would he.

yes he is important to us but i would have laughed at that, what an enbarrasment

he would'nt playing for us then would he.[/quote]


he would be a Taxmans dream

Has anyone got a link to a photo of him in this scarf?

Has anyone got a link to a photo of him in this scarf?

Pete Thomas will be uploading some photos tomorrow, unless they're already up on the official forum

i think hes been one of our best players this season and we badly miss him when we play without him

we are all entitled to our own opinions though