Sat Nov 21, 2020 4:58 pm
Sat Nov 21, 2020 5:02 pm
maccydee wrote:Gotta be worth a go moving forwards?
We created quite a bit last 15 with him on.
Sat Nov 21, 2020 5:48 pm
Sat Nov 21, 2020 6:01 pm
davids wrote:Much too inconsistent.
The enigma that is Josh Murphy was seen today.
His first cross when under no pressure was overhit straight out of play behind the goal.
His pass for the goal was sublime. In that moment you could see a glimpse of what could be an £11m player.
But he needs to do so much more and much more regularly to justify starting a game when you consider that even the desperately disappointing Junior Hoilett is regularly picked ahead of him.
Sat Nov 21, 2020 6:10 pm
Sat Nov 21, 2020 6:12 pm
maccydee wrote:davids wrote:Much too inconsistent.
The enigma that is Josh Murphy was seen today.
His first cross when under no pressure was overhit straight out of play behind the goal.
His pass for the goal was sublime. In that moment you could see a glimpse of what could be an £11m player.
But he needs to do so much more and much more regularly to justify starting a game when you consider that even the desperately disappointing Junior Hoilett is regularly picked ahead of him.
And then almost set up Wilson too.
That’s my point. He needs to be backed.
Sat Nov 21, 2020 8:33 pm
Sat Nov 21, 2020 8:44 pm
Sat Nov 21, 2020 9:26 pm
Sat Nov 21, 2020 9:42 pm
maccydee wrote:davids wrote:Much too inconsistent.
The enigma that is Josh Murphy was seen today.
His first cross when under no pressure was overhit straight out of play behind the goal.
His pass for the goal was sublime. In that moment you could see a glimpse of what could be an £11m player.
But he needs to do so much more and much more regularly to justify starting a game when you consider that even the desperately disappointing Junior Hoilett is regularly picked ahead of him.
And then almost set up Wilson too.
That’s my point. He needs to be backed.
Sat Nov 21, 2020 11:52 pm
Sun Nov 22, 2020 2:16 am
Llantwit Blue wrote:Murphy hasn’t got the heart the fight in him. First ball today cross straight into the stand he played a fantastic ball into Moore for the goal but one pass doesn’t justify his place in the team wages he has to be more consistent and 2 years in I am still waiting on a return for our 11 million.
Sun Nov 22, 2020 10:07 am
skidemin wrote:Llantwit Blue wrote:Murphy hasn’t got the heart the fight in him. First ball today cross straight into the stand he played a fantastic ball into Moore for the goal but one pass doesn’t justify his place in the team wages he has to be more consistent and 2 years in I am still waiting on a return for our 11 million.
but it does mate... 1 pass in 15 minutes that produces our only goal does justify...moments change games and he can always produce a few...
Sun Nov 22, 2020 10:12 am
davids wrote:Much too inconsistent.
The enigma that is Josh Murphy was seen today.
His first cross when under no pressure was overhit straight out of play behind the goal.
His pass for the goal was sublime. In that moment you could see a glimpse of what could be an £11m player.
But he needs to do so much more and much more regularly to justify starting a game when you consider that even the desperately disappointing Junior Hoilett is regularly picked ahead of him.
Sun Nov 22, 2020 10:13 am
maccydee wrote:davids wrote:Much too inconsistent.
The enigma that is Josh Murphy was seen today.
His first cross when under no pressure was overhit straight out of play behind the goal.
His pass for the goal was sublime. In that moment you could see a glimpse of what could be an £11m player.
But he needs to do so much more and much more regularly to justify starting a game when you consider that even the desperately disappointing Junior Hoilett is regularly picked ahead of him.
And then almost set up Wilson too.
That’s my point. He needs to be backed.
Sun Nov 22, 2020 10:13 am
Big Hill Blue wrote:£11m player. He needs to play every minute. Harris too defensive, too cautious.
We need to play from minute 1 to 90 on the front foot.
Sun Nov 22, 2020 10:16 am
skidemin wrote:Llantwit Blue wrote:Murphy hasn’t got the heart the fight in him. First ball today cross straight into the stand he played a fantastic ball into Moore for the goal but one pass doesn’t justify his place in the team wages he has to be more consistent and 2 years in I am still waiting on a return for our 11 million.
but it does mate... 1 pass in 15 minutes that produces our only goal does justify...moments change games and he can always produce a few...
Sun Nov 22, 2020 12:59 pm
Ponty Bluebird wrote:skidemin wrote:Llantwit Blue wrote:Murphy hasn’t got the heart the fight in him. First ball today cross straight into the stand he played a fantastic ball into Moore for the goal but one pass doesn’t justify his place in the team wages he has to be more consistent and 2 years in I am still waiting on a return for our 11 million.
but it does mate... 1 pass in 15 minutes that produces our only goal does justify...moments change games and he can always produce a few...
Exactly
Sun Nov 22, 2020 1:12 pm
piledriver64 wrote:maccydee wrote:davids wrote:Much too inconsistent.
The enigma that is Josh Murphy was seen today.
His first cross when under no pressure was overhit straight out of play behind the goal.
His pass for the goal was sublime. In that moment you could see a glimpse of what could be an £11m player.
But he needs to do so much more and much more regularly to justify starting a game when you consider that even the desperately disappointing Junior Hoilett is regularly picked ahead of him.
And then almost set up Wilson too.
That’s my point. He needs to be backed.
The trouble is that he has been backed Time and time again and performed in the odd game.
Not many of us doubt his ability. The majority of doubt his ability to perform in more than two games in a row.
We simply cannot rely/depend on him.
Sun Nov 22, 2020 1:14 pm
Sun Nov 22, 2020 1:24 pm
maccydee wrote:When he plays he scores goals and produces assists.
Tomlin does the same without much else really and Tomlin isn’t fit.
Give him a consistent go. I’d tell him that he has 10 games to impress.
Sun Nov 22, 2020 1:55 pm
bluebirdoct1962 wrote:maccydee wrote:When he plays he scores goals and produces assists.
Tomlin does the same without much else really and Tomlin isn’t fit.
Give him a consistent go. I’d tell him that he has 10 games to impress.
Mac I usually agree with all your posts but this is a first!!
I don’t think any player should be told ‘you have 10 games’ but based on Saturday I’d start him at 10 on Saturday with Hoillett and Wilson on wings. They can have the licence to switch around too.
Do you think Benkovic should start mate?
Sun Nov 22, 2020 2:13 pm
maccydee wrote:bluebirdoct1962 wrote:maccydee wrote:When he plays he scores goals and produces assists.
Tomlin does the same without much else really and Tomlin isn’t fit.
Give him a consistent go. I’d tell him that he has 10 games to impress.
Mac I usually agree with all your posts but this is a first!!
I don’t think any player should be told ‘you have 10 games’ but based on Saturday I’d start him at 10 on Saturday with Hoillett and Wilson on wings. They can have the licence to switch around too.
Do you think Benkovic should start mate?
It’s more for confidence with Murphy. I think it would bring the best out in both of them. That’s both sides of Murphy.
Yeah I would play Benkovic and Nelson at right back. This would free Bacuna to play centre mid again and put a bit of oomph into centre mid. I’m not sure what Vaulks has done wrong either.
Sun Nov 22, 2020 2:37 pm
maccydee wrote:skidemin wrote:Llantwit Blue wrote:Murphy hasn’t got the heart the fight in him. First ball today cross straight into the stand he played a fantastic ball into Moore for the goal but one pass doesn’t justify his place in the team wages he has to be more consistent and 2 years in I am still waiting on a return for our 11 million.
but it does mate... 1 pass in 15 minutes that produces our only goal does justify...moments change games and he can always produce a few...
Agree with this.
And a class ball for Wilson. Lucky save by the keeper.
Him, Wilson, Ojo and Moore could do some damage.
Sun Nov 22, 2020 4:19 pm
skidemin wrote:Llantwit Blue wrote:Murphy hasn’t got the heart the fight in him. First ball today cross straight into the stand he played a fantastic ball into Moore for the goal but one pass doesn’t justify his place in the team wages he has to be more consistent and 2 years in I am still waiting on a return for our 11 million.
but it does mate... 1 pass in 15 minutes that produces our only goal does justify...moments change games and he can always produce a few...
Sun Nov 22, 2020 6:17 pm
Sun Nov 22, 2020 6:59 pm
nubbsy wrote:skidemin wrote:Llantwit Blue wrote:Murphy hasn’t got the heart the fight in him. First ball today cross straight into the stand he played a fantastic ball into Moore for the goal but one pass doesn’t justify his place in the team wages he has to be more consistent and 2 years in I am still waiting on a return for our 11 million.
but it does mate... 1 pass in 15 minutes that produces our only goal does justify...moments change games and he can always produce a few...
Nah I'm sorry he's had plenty of game time over the past 3 years and the main reason he hasn't played much is because he hasn't taken the chances. Terrible signing.
Sun Nov 22, 2020 8:50 pm