Tue Jan 12, 2021 3:20 pm
Tue Jan 12, 2021 3:22 pm
Tue Jan 12, 2021 3:53 pm
Tue Jan 12, 2021 4:35 pm
Tue Jan 12, 2021 4:55 pm
Tue Jan 12, 2021 6:23 pm
Tue Jan 12, 2021 6:51 pm
skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Tue Jan 12, 2021 7:20 pm
thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
Tue Jan 12, 2021 7:43 pm
skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
yep thats what he did...now go on give me half a dozen managers who have turned such a poor start { 8 points from 11 } into better than Bowen achieved....no harris hasnt and neither has pep....
expectations off the scale...
Tue Jan 12, 2021 7:53 pm
thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
yep thats what he did...now go on give me half a dozen managers who have turned such a poor start { 8 points from 11 } into better than Bowen achieved....no harris hasnt and neither has pep....
expectations off the scale...
He made a average team have a average season
Nothing more nothing less
He certainly couldn't be seen as a success , just did his job.
Tue Jan 12, 2021 7:53 pm
thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
yep thats what he did...now go on give me half a dozen managers who have turned such a poor start { 8 points from 11 } into better than Bowen achieved....no harris hasnt and neither has pep....
expectations off the scale...
He made a average team have a average season
Nothing more nothing less
He certainly couldn't be seen as a success , just did his job.
Tue Jan 12, 2021 8:01 pm
JasonFowler1991 wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
yep thats what he did...now go on give me half a dozen managers who have turned such a poor start { 8 points from 11 } into better than Bowen achieved....no harris hasnt and neither has pep....
expectations off the scale...
He made a average team have a average season
Nothing more nothing less
He certainly couldn't be seen as a success , just did his job.
I was reading a Reading blog. They wrote that he should probably have been given more time, that they did OK but lacked a playing style and we're overly defensive.
Link: https://thetilehurstend.sbnation.com/20 ... -fc-royals
Tue Jan 12, 2021 8:23 pm
skidemin wrote:JasonFowler1991 wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
yep thats what he did...now go on give me half a dozen managers who have turned such a poor start { 8 points from 11 } into better than Bowen achieved....no harris hasnt and neither has pep....
expectations off the scale...
He made a average team have a average season
Nothing more nothing less
He certainly couldn't be seen as a success , just did his job.
I was reading a Reading blog. They wrote that he should probably have been given more time, that they did OK but lacked a playing style and we're overly defensive.
Link: https://thetilehurstend.sbnation.com/20 ... -fc-royals
yes id imagine a team in a relegation battle wouldnt look much like Man Citeh... he wouldnt be top of my want list but credit where its due....
Tue Jan 12, 2021 8:32 pm
thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:JasonFowler1991 wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
yep thats what he did...now go on give me half a dozen managers who have turned such a poor start { 8 points from 11 } into better than Bowen achieved....no harris hasnt and neither has pep....
expectations off the scale...
He made a average team have a average season
Nothing more nothing less
He certainly couldn't be seen as a success , just did his job.
I was reading a Reading blog. They wrote that he should probably have been given more time, that they did OK but lacked a playing style and we're overly defensive.
Link: https://thetilehurstend.sbnation.com/20 ... -fc-royals
yes id imagine a team in a relegation battle wouldnt look much like Man Citeh... he wouldnt be top of my want list but credit where its due....
Don't get me wrong he did the job asked of him but I wouldnt say it was overly successful.
Do people deserve credit for just doing the basics of the job ?
I base success on going over and above what is expected of them
Tue Jan 12, 2021 8:40 pm
JasonFowler1991 wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:JasonFowler1991 wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
yep thats what he did...now go on give me half a dozen managers who have turned such a poor start { 8 points from 11 } into better than Bowen achieved....no harris hasnt and neither has pep....
expectations off the scale...
He made a average team have a average season
Nothing more nothing less
He certainly couldn't be seen as a success , just did his job.
I was reading a Reading blog. They wrote that he should probably have been given more time, that they did OK but lacked a playing style and we're overly defensive.
Link: https://thetilehurstend.sbnation.com/20 ... -fc-royals
yes id imagine a team in a relegation battle wouldnt look much like Man Citeh... he wouldnt be top of my want list but credit where its due....
Don't get me wrong he did the job asked of him but I wouldnt say it was overly successful.
Do people deserve credit for just doing the basics of the job ?
I base success on going over and above what is expected of them
At the time of Neil Harris taking over there were just 2 points between us and Reading. By the end of the season there was a 17 point margin.
What Bowen did at Reading was less impressive than what Harris achieved here. It would be very underwhelming.
Tue Jan 12, 2021 8:50 pm
skidemin wrote:JasonFowler1991 wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:JasonFowler1991 wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
yep thats what he did...now go on give me half a dozen managers who have turned such a poor start { 8 points from 11 } into better than Bowen achieved....no harris hasnt and neither has pep....
expectations off the scale...
He made a average team have a average season
Nothing more nothing less
He certainly couldn't be seen as a success , just did his job.
I was reading a Reading blog. They wrote that he should probably have been given more time, that they did OK but lacked a playing style and we're overly defensive.
Link: https://thetilehurstend.sbnation.com/20 ... -fc-royals
yes id imagine a team in a relegation battle wouldnt look much like Man Citeh... he wouldnt be top of my want list but credit where its due....
Don't get me wrong he did the job asked of him but I wouldnt say it was overly successful.
Do people deserve credit for just doing the basics of the job ?
I base success on going over and above what is expected of them
At the time of Neil Harris taking over there were just 2 points between us and Reading. By the end of the season there was a 17 point margin.
What Bowen did at Reading was less impressive than what Harris achieved here. It would be very underwhelming.
well id imagine getting more points than the vast amount of managers have managed from that starting point is above what could be expected.... if you think that achieving far more than the majority have is what is expected your expectations are too high...
Tue Jan 12, 2021 10:25 pm
Tue Jan 12, 2021 10:28 pm
JasonFowler1991 wrote:I can't see any other reason than these 3 being Welsh, and connected with CCFC for wanting this.
Legg and Bowen have both failed as managers, I'm not aware of Bellamy's achievements as a coach, but he has no managerial experience. Remember when we tried Scott Young, Gabbidon and Trollope all for similar reasons, all failed.
If Harris does leave, I accept the budget will be low, but I for sure hope we are looking at someone with any type of experience and success as a manager, at any level.
Tue Jan 12, 2021 10:30 pm
JasonFowler1991 wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:JasonFowler1991 wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:skidemin wrote:thomasblue wrote:So a team with very little experience between them of management at this level
Mark Bowen had less than a season at Reading and failed
Bellamy has coached a few kids
Andy legg has only managed at Parks level sides in the LOW
Not exactly a dream team and none would be mentioned for any vacancy here if they didn't have Welsh links
We need a proper manager in charge not gamble on someone because his grandmothers mother made him eligible to play for Wales or they appeared for us a few times.
Any of them as a number 2 or in the set up would be OK but we need proper experianced leadership
failed...id call Bowens time at Reading as a success....
Took over a as caretaker , won manager of the month once and ended up 14th in the final table
Wow
If thats success then Harris is Guardiola
yep thats what he did...now go on give me half a dozen managers who have turned such a poor start { 8 points from 11 } into better than Bowen achieved....no harris hasnt and neither has pep....
expectations off the scale...
He made a average team have a average season
Nothing more nothing less
He certainly couldn't be seen as a success , just did his job.
I was reading a Reading blog. They wrote that he should probably have been given more time, that they did OK but lacked a playing style and we're overly defensive.
Link: https://thetilehurstend.sbnation.com/20 ... -fc-royals
yes id imagine a team in a relegation battle wouldnt look much like Man Citeh... he wouldnt be top of my want list but credit where its due....
Don't get me wrong he did the job asked of him but I wouldnt say it was overly successful.
Do people deserve credit for just doing the basics of the job ?
I base success on going over and above what is expected of them
At the time of Neil Harris taking over there were just 2 points between us and Reading. By the end of the season there was a 17 point margin.
What Bowen did at Reading was less impressive than what Harris achieved here. It would be very underwhelming.
Tue Jan 12, 2021 11:58 pm
HarriRhys22 wrote:JasonFowler1991 wrote:I can't see any other reason than these 3 being Welsh, and connected with CCFC for wanting this.
Legg and Bowen have both failed as managers, I'm not aware of Bellamy's achievements as a coach, but he has no managerial experience. Remember when we tried Scott Young, Gabbidon and Trollope all for similar reasons, all failed.
If Harris does leave, I accept the budget will be low, but I for sure hope we are looking at someone with any type of experience and success as a manager, at any level.
I thought we were Capital of Wales not just another English club in the English Championship?